After 100 days of war in Ukraine, the next weeks will be crucial.
The war in Ukraine has slogged on for 100 days, and those who claim to know where it’s headed are kidding themselves.
Back on Feb. 24, when Russian forces invaded on three fronts, the most optimistic prediction from the Ukrainian vantage was that Kyiv would fall within a few weeks, if not a few days, but that resistance fighters would bog the Russians down in a quagmire for months or even years. No one was predicting that by June, President Volodymyr Zelensky would still reside in the capital as president or that both sides’ armies would still be locked in combat.
In some ways, the world knows a lot about what’s going on in this war (thanks to publicly available satellite imagery). In other ways, we know very little (the axiomatic “fog of war”). And in still other ways, we’re led (by sometimes faulty intelligence leaks) or misled (through press releases by various defense ministries) to think we know a lot more than we really do. This scramble of hard data, vague guesswork, and propaganda is then churned through the 24/7 news machine, which calls on experts of various stripes and calibers to keep score, declare winners and losers, and predict what happens next.
And so, early on, when the Russian army turned out to be a lot worse than many expected and the Ukrainians turned out to be a lot better, many declared that Ukraine was going to win. More recently, as the Russians shifted their strategy to focus on the eastern Donbas region and began to make advances, yesterday’s optimists turned dour and warned that Ukraine might lose unless the West stepped up its delivery of heavy armaments. Now the West is doing just that, and the contest seems to be one of time. Will Russian rockets demolish Ukrainian troop positions before the arrival of those new weapons? Will the new systems allow Ukrainian rockets to demolish Russian positions in return—or will they come too late?
AdvertisementBut even this view is too narrow—a throwback to the “body count” comparisons of the Vietnam War’s nightly news briefings. (It now appears that Ukraine and Russia have lost a roughly equal number of soldiers, somewhere over 10,000—a fact that’s alarming but not particularly enlightening.)
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementSome analysts are doing more meticulous analysis, notably Michael Kofman’s battlefield updates for the research firm CNA, and the Institute for the Study of War’s near-daily “Russian Offensive Campaign Assessments.” There you can find the most fine-grained detail available on who controls what patches of territory, with what strategic consequences, in the ever-shifting front lines of lethal fire. Even so, these analysts admit that the overall picture is hazy and reveals little about who’s winning or losing in any meaningful sense.
AdvertisementOne reason for this is that it’s unclear what “winning” and “losing” mean—or how the combatants and their allies define those terms. Zelensky has said he would be willing to negotiate with Russian President Vladimir Putin once the pre–Feb. 24 borders are restored. Does this mean all Russian troops must leave Ukrainian territory? Does that include all of Donbas, or can the troops stay in the areas previously occupied by pro-Russia separatist militias? And what about Crimea, which most countries formally recognize as part of Ukraine but which Russia, having captured it without firing a bullet in 2014, is extremely unlikely to let go? Meanwhile, Putin and his aides continue to demonize Zelensky’s government as Nazi puppets of an imperialist West and to dispute Ukraine’s existence as a sovereign state. If Putin holds to this line, negotiations are out of the question; victory, by this standard, means not only occupying Donbas but another go at invading Kyiv and beyond—essentially Ukraine’s obliteration.
Advertisement AdvertisementPutin’s talk could, of course, be just that: a way to consolidate support among the Russian population. He might also think that if he declared a more modest goal, Zelensky might take it as a sign of weakness and respond by stepping up Ukraine’s offensives.
AdvertisementIn any case, neither side has an incentive to stop fighting now, especially since both sides probably detect the chance of a breakthrough in the weeks ahead. In recent weeks, Russia has been pummeling Ukrainian positions with artillery rockets, and Ukraine’s rockets don’t have the range to fire back. The new U.S. rockets President Joe Biden is sending will match the Russians’ range, and therefore shift the balance of power. It will take a few weeks, however, to ship the weapons, then train Ukrainians (probably in Poland) in how to use them. How much damage will the Russian pummeling do in the meantime?
AdvertisementPopular in News & Politics
- Sure Sounds Like the Supreme Court Is About to Give Trump a Big Win!
- Trump Is Trying Something New With the 2024 Campaign. It’s Smart—and Terrifying.
- We Can Learn a Lot From the Weird Crew That Keeps Showing Up to Trump’s Trial
- Did That Have to Happen at Columbia? No. Just Look at What Happened at Brown.
Meanwhile, the Russians are running short on vital resources as well: manpower (due to deaths, desertions, and Putin’s decision to go to war with too few troops to begin with), weapons (a quarter of their tanks lost in battle), and, perhaps most significant, morale. Putin is not deluded about any of this. He knows that his army has performed poorly; hence his firing of at least five top generals just this week. However, he also knows—in recent weeks, a number of Western eminences and analysts have given voice to this—that the West is losing patience for this war and the economic devastation that it is wreaking worldwide. He is hoping that if he can keep up the barrage for a little longer, the patience might snap and the pressure might build for Zelensky to make some kind of deal.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementWhether or not any of these hopes or fears come to pass, a larger question remains: What happens to Ukraine once the fighting stops? The devastation has been immense. Russia seems intent not so much on reoccupying the country but on wiping it out. In any case, the recovery will be extremely expensive. At the end of World War II, the United States emerged with sufficient power and wealth to help rebuild Western Europe through the Marshall Plan and other forms of aid and investment. It’s not at all clear who will have the resources and the political will to do the same to rebuild Ukraine at the end of this.
For all these reasons, the war is likely to go on for quite a while longer. And the picture of where it’s going—who’s winning—is likely to remain murky.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- Foreign, multicultural students rise amid declining school population
- Ronaldo salvages point for Man Utd against Chelsea
- Diana using football knowledge in cricket
- After Kennedy's retirement, are we entering 'Handmaid's Tale' territory?
- Pakistan to host South Africa before ICC Women’s T20 World Cup
- Alcaraz vs. Van de Zandschulp 2024 livestream: Watch US Open for free
- Sanders praises Trump for North Korea peace efforts
- Political heavyweights moving to run as independents in April 13 poll
- North Korean media staff in Vietnam [PHOTOS]
- First officially approved Gen IV nuclear reactor in the US breaks ground
- Adele posts heartwarming message to fans after finishing tour
- Japan not drafting UN resolution on Pyongyang's human rights abuse
- FM Yun calls for all
-
海丰芥蓝入选全国名特优新农产品名录_南方+_南方plus日前,农业农村部农产品质量安全中心公布了2024年度全国名特优新农产品名录,“海丰芥蓝”成功入选,海丰名物再添一员!“南海物丰”,海丰县属南亚热 ...[详细]
-
看表演、赶大集、送文创……这周末在海心沙赚足了年味!_南方+_南方plus写春联、送利是、逛美食……年关将至,囤年货承载着人们对新年的期望和祝福。置办年货的过程是人们迎接新年的重要仪式之一。如今,年货 ...[详细]
-
Moving moment Kate Middleton hugs crying mum of autistic boy
LONDON -- The Duchess of Cambridge hugged a mother who started crying when her son told the royal ab ...[详细] -
China urges North Korea to comply with U.N. resolutions over threat of nuke warhead test
China on Tuesday called for North Korea to comply with U.N. resolutions, responding to a threat by t ...[详细] -
How much for Oasis tickets? Fans joke about splurging on reunion shows
Oasis, one of the biggest bands ever, broke up for 15 years because of a longtime feud between broth ...[详细] -
Defense Ministry dismisses N.K.’s missile claim
South Korea’s Defense Ministry on Tuesday cast doubts on North Korea’s ability to ensure that its in ...[详细] -
The Internet of Things now includes everything and the kitchen sink
Everything's voice-activated these days -- even the kitchen sink.The Delta Faucet Company announced ...[详细] -
Instagram on desktop is way better for being a creep
This isOde To..., a weekly column where we share the stuff we're really into in hopes that you'll be ...[详细] -
I used the Pixel 9 Pro XL in the shower — does the screen work when wet as claimed?
The Pixel 9 Pro XL came out swinging with an impressive set of features that threaten Samsung and Ap ...[详细] -
百款年鱼产品集体亮相!珠海两地年鱼大集正式开市_南方+_南方plus2024年1月19日珠澳臻品年货嘉年华暨直播电商节在珠海市体育中心隆重开幕珠澳有好市,祥龙献优品1月19-21日三天持续欢乐购活动上 ...[详细]
Michael Cohen fights Donald Trump at the Supreme Court.
Kim inspects landing drills, orders enemies be buried at sea
- US to oppose North Korean worker dispatch to occupied Ukrainian territory: State Dept.
- Gina Rodriguez paid for an undocumented immigrant to attend college
- Alex edges Ko Jin
- City, Liverpool turn attention back to EPL
- DOJ accuses TikTok of collecting and sharing users' personal views, as the app fights a ban
- 市民:商品房质量保修有什么规定?
- Defense Ministry dismisses N.K.’s missile claim