New START: Biden has just days to save a key nuclear treaty with Russia.
Some Senate Republicans are urging President Joe Biden not to renew the New Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty, or New START, which expires on Feb. 5. They are wrong. The treaty benefits the United States and Russia—in some ways, us more than the Russians—without harming either. In any case, Congress has no say in the matter. Article XIV of the treaty—which more than two-thirds of the Senate ratified in 2010—permits the two countries to extend its terms by up to five years with a simple stroke of the pen. Both Biden and President Vladimir Putin are keen to extend the treaty, while Donald Trump wanted to let it lapse.
The treaty—which was signed by then-Presidents Barack Obama and Dmitry Medvedev—limits each side to 1,550 nuclear warheads on long-range missiles and bombers. Meeting this limit required only modest reductions. But New START also imposes highly intrusive procedures to verify that neither side is cheating. Each side has to notify the other whenever it produces, deploys, or moves a missile, warhead, or bomber (Russia has issued 20,000 such notifications in the decade since the treaty went into effect). And each side can demand up to 18 on-site inspections of the other side’s weapons sites per year—in addition to the intelligence gained from spy satellites and other monitoring.
Since the U.S. is relatively open about its nuclear activities (anyone can read about them in congressional hearings) and Russia is relatively closed, these inspections and notifications give us an inside peek that we wouldn’t otherwise have.
And the treaty has been effective. Though critics complain that Russia has violated most of the other arms control treaties it has signed, nobody seriously contends that it has cheated on New START—the only treaty that restricts the U.S. weapons that can destroy Russia and the Russian weapons that can destroy the U.S.
AdvertisementFinally, no U.S. military officers are chomping at the bit to build more nukes. (Many want new nukes to replace the existing ones, but that’s a different issue.) A special unit at U.S. Strategic Command draws up nuclear war plans to conform to the limits set by the treaty, and no one in the unit has complained that they don’t have enough weapons to do whatever it is they think they might need to do.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementIn fact, shortly after signing New START, Obama ordered a detailed review of the nuclear war plan. Senior officials from the White House, the Pentagon, and StratCom spent months poring over the plan in excruciating detail—examining how many U.S. warheads were aimed at each Russian target and whether so many were needed. In the end, the officials all concluded that the arsenal could be cut by an additional one-third—from 1,550 to roughly 1,000—with no harm to national security. (I describe this highly classified exercise in my 2020 bookThe Bomb, which—shameless plug—comes out in paperback next week.)
AdvertisementThe Joint Chiefs of Staff affirmed the group’s report, but told Obama that they would not endorse any cuts of that size unless the Russians made similar cuts in their arsenal. Obama had hoped that New START would spark talks for a follow-on treaty, but Russia’s annexation of Crimea and its armed incursion into eastern Ukraine quashed those hopes.
The point here, though, is that New START gives StratCom more than enough weapons. There is no rationale for letting the treaty lapse in order to build more.
But those who want to end New START make a different argument. They note that the treaty restricts only long-range weapons. Therefore, they argue, before the U.S. agrees on an extension, Russia should cut the number of its short-range nuclear weapons in Europe. They also insist that China should join the treaty, so that its growing arsenal can be cut down in size as well.
Advertisement AdvertisementRussia does have about 2,000 nukes that could hit targets in Europe. There is much concern about these “tactical” nukes, but few believe they give Russia a real advantage in the event of war. In any case, no U.S. officers have argued that we need to put thousands of nukes in Europe to match. Russia has nukes in Europe primarily as a way to counter what they see as U.S. and NATO superiority in conventional arms on the continent—just as, in the 1960s to ’70s, the U.S. had as many as 7,000 short-range nukes in Western Europe to counter the Soviet and Warsaw Pact’s conventional edge.
AdvertisementIn other words, it is unlikely that Russia will get rid of those short-range nukes. Nor is it likely to adopt some formula that includes them in some treaty that allows each side an equal number of totalnuclear weapons—short-range and long-range combined. Such a treaty would give the U.S. numerical superiority in long-range weapons, which Russia would regard as politically unacceptable. If we lack the leverage to cut their short-range nukes, it’s best to retain the limits on their long-range ones.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementAs for China, it makes no sense to include that country in a follow-up to New START. China has only about 300 nuclear weapons. Its leaders have no desire to join a treaty with the U.S. and Russia. If they did join, they would soon demand parity. In other words, simply putting them in the forum would give them an incentive to build a lot more nuclear weapons than they have now. China has never been engaged in a nuclear arms race with either country. Its nuclear policy has been mainly to build enough weapons to deter either country from attacking it. It has enough to do that. Why give them the slightest excuse to build more?
The real reason most critics want to finish off New START is that they don’t like arms control treaties, period. They fear that any internationally imposed restraint, however beneficial, inherently shackles our sovereignty. They also fear that any reduction in tensions with our adversaries—any forum that gives us more cause for dialogue and trust (or at least less distrust)—is prone to make us complacent and is, therefore, dangerous.
AdvertisementPopular in News & Politics
- The Meltdown in Michigan Says It All About Where MAGA Is Headed
- When Stormy Daniels Told Her Story in Court, the Absurd Horror of This Trial Finally Hit Home
- Donald Trump Really Did This to Himself
- Kristi Noem’s Book Has a New, Non-Dog-Killing Scandal
This is the worst kind of shortsightedness. Even for those who aren’t keen about nuclear disarmament, arms control treaties are a valuable way to “bound the threat.” Without New START’s verification procedures, U.S. intelligence agencies would draw up worst-case scenarios on how large the Russian arsenal mightgrow. In response, StratCom’s generals would demand more weapons in response. If New START is extended, we will know the size of Russia’s arsenal for the next five years—muffling the alarm bells.
Moscow and Washington aren’t on good terms, to say the least. Russia’s interference with the 2016 election and, more recently, its massive hacking of SolarWinds mark it as, in many ways, a threat. However, this was true, to an even greater degree, during the last three decades of the Cold War, when the U.S. and Soviet Union negotiated several arms control treaties, cooperated to fight terrorism, and even jointly developed a smallpox vaccine. Then as now, we have common and converging interests, and it’s worth pursuing those, whatever else is going on.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:关于我们)
-
高燃!哨响表停赛不止,2024广东“村BA”开赛在即,一分钟带你重温高光瞬间。
...[详细] -
5月19日晚,荥经县严道镇一名11岁孩子与妈妈扯皮后负气离家出走,家人寻找无果,心急如焚地报警求助。警方派出大量警力,展开拉网式排查,全力搜寻离家出走的孩子,最终将其找到,交给家长带回家。孩子离家一夜 ...[详细]
-
成都大运会运动员与湛江金鲳鱼竞渡蓝海去何方?8月27日,答案揭晓
成都大运会运动员与湛江金鲳鱼竞渡蓝海去何方?8月27日,答案揭晓_南方+_南方plus竞渡大蓝海——广东金鲳鱼进四川品牌推介活动系列海报①【文案】韩安东 唐瑞谦【设计】曾梓毅【来源】南方农村报 ...[详细] -
□ 杨青临近中秋,在浓厚的节日气氛之下,不少人也会发现,近年来我国许多传统节日,正在经历着不同程度的改变。而这些变化的结果,既反映着现代社会中人们观念与思想的革新,又为我们传递着文化之“变”的信号。发 ...[详细]
-
“笋货”上市采购旺!清远西牛麻竹笋迎秋季尝鲜热_南方+_南方plus西牛麻竹笋,尝鲜正当时!进入八月以来,清远英德的西牛麻竹笋加工企业正加足马力迎接上市旺季。素有“蔬中第一珍”之誉的西牛麻竹笋正次第拔 ...[详细]
-
雅安日报/北纬网讯昨(11)日,记者从市纪委获悉,本月13日前,市纪委组织的8个检查小组,将对市级部门、县(区)四套领导班子是否存在公款送礼、公款吃喝、违规发放津补贴、公款旅游、公车私用等违反八项规定 ...[详细]
-
化州平定镇化橘红)入选首批国家农业产业强镇名单_南方+_南方plus近日,农业农村部办公厅、财政部办公厅联合发布《首批国家农业产业强镇名单》,广东共29个镇入选名单。化州市平定镇化橘红)榜上有名。国家 ...[详细]
-
雅安日报讯3日,记者从中国茶文化周活动组委会发布的信息获知,“蒙顶山茶”获得百年世博中国名茶金奖,同时,四川省蒙顶皇茶茶业有限公司的“蒙顶牌蒙顶黄芽”获得百年世博中国名茶金骆驼奖。这意味着蒙顶山茶将代 ...[详细]
-
'Black Myth: Wukong' PS5 review in progress: A potential masterpiece
Black Myth: Wukongwantsto be the modern action RPG we’ve all been waiting for. It checks all t ...[详细] -
340个作品入围!广东农产品品牌最高奖红荔奖初赛晋级名单公示
340个作品入围!广东农产品品牌最高奖红荔奖初赛晋级名单公示_南方+_南方plus初赛晋级名单正式出炉!9月17日,中国国际农产品品牌建设运营广东)邀请大赛红荔奖)以下简称“红荔奖”)初赛评审圆满结束 ...[详细]