Is the gig economy bill a disaster or triumph for ride
Uber and Lyft have been warning drivers about the end of flexible schedules, and passengers about more expensive rides that take longer to arrive, all thanks to a California bill that passed this week.
But drivers and other gig workers are celebrating what could be a pathway to fair pay, benefits, and other employee rights, which some claim will come at only a slight cost to riders.
After the bill, called AB5, makes its way to the governor's desk, it should go into effect on Jan. 1, 2020. It would make companies reclassify many independent contractors as employees, something Uber and Lyft have opposed.
While this would directly affect drivers and other gig economy workers, like the 200,000 in California working for Uber, the people who use the apps could also see changes.
The New York Timescited "industry officials" who say costs for companies like Uber and Lyft could rise by 20 to 30 percent because of AB5. Other industry experts like Michael Droke, a partner at Dorsey & Whitney in California, a law firm that has represented big companies like 3M and Wells Fargo in labor disputes, also sees costs going up for companies and prices going up for riders.
"Many industries rely on independent contractors to deliver products and services, from food delivery to software coding and design. Those workers will be converted to employees, significantly increasing the cost of the products and services," Droke said.
Yaël Ossowski, deputy director of the Consumer Choice Center, which supports deregulation, said the law could force people to "seek out alternatives." Instead of ordering a cheap ride, he thinks people will be forced to do things like carpool, hail a cab, or find a nearby bus.
For Uber and Lyft driver Jeff Perry, AB5 is a huge win. He is part of Gig Workers Rising, which has been instrumental in gathering support for the bill and is fighting for drivers to unionize.
He's not concerned that Uber or Lyft will go out of business or that customers will turn to other options. He said passengers will understand potentially longer wait times and higher prices are a necessary sacrifice to help drivers.
"It's better than anything cabs can offer or public transit," he said.
Perry thinks Uber and Lyft can innovate again in the face of a new employee structure and costs.
"I don't feel sorry in the least for Uber," he said. "I don't think this is as dire for them as they make it seem."
He referenced an in-app message that Lyft sent out Wednesday morning in response to AB5 moving forward. He saw it as a last-ditch effort to get drivers to pressure California Gov. Gavin Newsom to veto the bill.
Tweet may have been deleted
Aside from somewhat longer wait times and higher fares, Gary Buffo, president of the National Limousine Association, which has supported better pay and benefits for ride-hailing drivers, doesn't think Uber or Lyft need to paint AB5 as a disaster.
He's seen his industry survive while following standard labor practices for its drivers, so he believes these companies can handle it.
"Nobody is going to see a big change at all," he said in a call Wednesday. "Except Uber and Lyft drivers getting paid fairly."
SEE ALSO:The bill Uber and Lyft fought against passed, and it could shake up the gig economyIn Uber and Lyft's IPO filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission earlier this year, the switch from independent contractor to employee is listed as potentially ruinous.
"If the contractor classification of drivers that use our platform is challenged, there may be adverse business, financial, tax, legal and other consequences," Lyft's filing states.
Uber clearly lists in a bullet point: "Our business would be adversely affected if Drivers were classified as employees instead of independent contractors."
In a press call Wednesday, Uber's chief legal officer Tony West said the ride-hailing company wants to give drivers organizing rights and minimum pay standards without forcing them to become employees.
"We believe drivers are properly classified as independent," he said, emphasizing driver flexibility. Uber plans to argue that its drivers can continue to use the platform as they always have. Combining forces with Lyft, Uber is backing a ballot initiative for California voters to set a separate ride-hailing driver policy.
Tweet may have been deleted
While unwilling to go into worst-case scenarios, West assured reporters that Uber would stick around. He even floated the possibility that nothing would change and AB5 wouldn't raise costs or cause any structural changes. As Gig Workers Rising's Perry said, there's undeniable value in Uber and Lyft — it just needs to include the drivers that power the service.
TopicsUberlyft
(责任编辑:资讯)
- 多措并举优治理 绘就幸福新图景
- Google might be making its own version of Apple's AirTags
- 吃猪肉,广东人是最认真的
- 雨城地税多措并举大力支持和促进就业
- [Graphic News] Average book price nears 20,000 won
- Korea's economy to stop growing without drastic labor change: FKI
- 我市著名画家耿继斌亮相川台《巴蜀画谈》
- 首付一成可买房?暂时还是个传说
- NK to launch 3 more spy satellites in 2024: KCNA
- CPUs Don't Matter For 4K Gaming... Wrong!
- Tinder will soon make its gender options more trans
- Apple receives patent for Apple Watch with a camera
- The latest 'Last Jedi' teaser could hint at a dark storyline for Rey
-
[Herald Review] Tori Kelly thrills fans, hints her love for Korean artists
Tori Kelly performs during her first concert in Korea held at Seoul, Tuesday. (Live Nation Korea)Ame ...[详细] -
AmazonSmile ending: Amazon is shutting down the charity program
AmazonSmile is the latest casualty in the company's cost-cutting efforts. On Wednesday, Amazon annou ...[详细] -
假期对于孩子们来说是最快乐的日子。这个假期,雅安的孩子们过得怎样?“青少年之家”作为青少年校外活动阵地,在青少年的暑期生活中有着举足轻重的作用。“4·20”芦山强烈地震后,为了关爱青少年的心理健康,帮 ...[详细]
-
Samsung Galaxy S23 vs S22: Specs, price, and more.
Samsung revealed its Galaxy S23 line of phones during its Samsung Galaxy Unpacked event on Wednesday ...[详细] -
Scientists detect water sloshing on Mars. There could be a lot.
A pioneering NASA robot detected over a thousand quakes on Mars. It also may have revealed a huge re ...[详细] -
雅安日报讯12日,芦山县千名建筑工匠培训行动圆满结束,1347名学员按期完成规定学习课程,投入灾区农房重建工作。芦山县重建办相关人员介绍,芦山县千名建筑工匠培训行动自7月1日全面启动以来,得到省委、市 ...[详细]
-
雅安日报讯12日,芦山县千名建筑工匠培训行动圆满结束,1347名学员按期完成规定学习课程,投入灾区农房重建工作。芦山县重建办相关人员介绍,芦山县千名建筑工匠培训行动自7月1日全面启动以来,得到省委、市 ...[详细]
-
South Korea’s local elections kicks off day after US
South Korea’s quadrennial local elections will kick off Wednesday at 6 a.m. across 14,134 polling ce ...[详细] -
阳江村K开麦,阳西3人晋级!| 2024广东乡村歌手大赛_南方+_南方plus8月20日晚,2024广东乡村歌手大赛阳江赛区正式开启。首场赛事在阳西县的“文化地标”——阳西县文化馆演艺厅拉开序幕。演艺 ...[详细]
-
东科·原山墅要为终年多雨,云雾迷蒙的雅安带来一种怎样的风格,以适合这里的阳光、空气、水土?为此,由老总亲自带队的工作组历时半年,多方考察论证,最终选择了温暖、明亮、朴素、富足的意式托斯卡纳风格。黄墙, ...[详细]
Sinner vs. Michelsen 2024 livestream: Watch US Open for free
Mastodon sees significant drop in users
- 特写|在农事定向大赛遇见和美乡村
- 从农场到餐桌,猪业盛会全产业链面面观
- AmazonSmile ending: Amazon is shutting down the charity program
- Getty is suing a popular AI image generator for copyright infringement
- Tesla's big software update includes something called 'Night Curfew'
- Gawker killer Peter Thiel may try to buy what's left of Gawker
- North Korea’s fertility rate reaches all