The Republicans who voted for Merrick Garland in 1997 are against him now.
President Obama’s decision to nominate Merrick Garland to the Supreme Court will make things more than a little awkward for a number of Senate Republicans who have vowed they won’t even consider the nomination. Blindly denying a vote to Garland, by pretty much all accounts a respected and relatively moderate judge, could hurt those senators who are up for re-election in purple or blue states, like Pennsylvania’s Pat Toomey and New Hampshire’s Kelly Ayotte. More immediately, though, Obama’s choice will leave more than a half-dozen senators who voted to confirm Garland to his current position scrambling to justify their newfound opposition to him.
Exhibit A: Sen. Orrin Hatch, a senior member of the Judiciary Committee, the panel that would be responsible for holding confirmation hearings on Garland—that is, if Republican leadership had not already ruled those out. Hatch is one of seven Republicans still in the Senate who voted to confirm Garland back in 1997 to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. Here is Hatch touting Garland’s qualifications on the Senate floor two decades ago:
AdvertisementAt the time, the Utah senator also called Garland “not only a fine nominee, but as good as Republicans can expect from [the Bill Clinton] administration.” In 2010, when Garland’s name was among those considered for the open Supreme Court slot that eventually went to Elena Kagan, Hatch said there was “no question” Garland could be confirmed if nominated. Flash forward to this past Friday, and Hatch was saying the same thing. “Obama could easily name Merrick Garland, who is a fine man,” he told the conservative website Newsmax on Friday while discussing the president’s impending announcement. Hatch then added: “He probably won’t do that because this appointment is about the election. So I’m pretty sure he’ll name someone the [liberal Democratic base] wants.”
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementAnd how did Hatch react to news of Garland’s impending nomination on Wednesday morning? “The right course of action is to wait until the next year’s election to consider a nominee to fill Justice Scalia’s seat,” the Utah senator told CBS News. Ah yes, of course.
Hatch isn’t alone. Republicans John McCain, Arizona; Susan Collins, Maine; Pat Roberts, Kansas; James Inhofe, Oklahoma; Dan Coats, Indiana; and Thad Cochran, Mississippi, also voted to confirm Garland in 1997. Many of those senators haven’t weighed in yet, but the early returns don’t look promising for Garland:
Advertisement AdvertisementWhy did you vote for Garland in 1997? "I supported him," Pat Roberts said to me. Will you support him now? "It's not about the person."
— Manu Raju (@mkraju) March 16, 2016
Even many of the Republicans who voted against Garland at the time said it had nothing to do with his qualifications, but instead were driven by the Republican belief that the D.C. appeals court has too many seats. Here’s what then-and-current Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley said at the time: “I have nothing against the nominee. Mr. Garland seems to be well qualified and would probably make a good judge—in some other court.” That other court is apparently not the Supreme. “A lifetime appointment that could dramatically impact individual freedoms and change the direction of the court for at least a generation is too important to get bogged down in politics,” Grassley said in a statement today. “The American people shouldn’t be denied a voice.”
Advertisement AdvertisementIn addition to Grassley, there are four other Republicans still serving in the Senate who voted against Garland back in 1997: Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, Jeff Sessions of Alabama, Richard Shelby of Alabama, and Mike Enzi of Wyoming. While their opposition was also about the size of the D.C. court and not the nominee himself, GOP leadership is already busy rewriting history. “This is an easy one. Both our leader and judiciary chairman voted against him when he was confirmed before and it’s a clear recognition by the White House that we mean what we say: There will be no confirmation,” a senior GOP aide told Politico. “If they thought we were going to cave, they would have put up a much different candidate.”
Read more on Obama’s nomination of Merrick Garland to the Supreme Court.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- US to oppose North Korean worker dispatch to occupied Ukrainian territory: State Dept.
- 16岁少年 带着父亲遗言 协助母亲撑起一个家
- 石棉县第二批拟开工项目前期准备工作基本就绪
- Amazon Prime Day deal: Save $40 on XREAL Air AR glasses
- Echo Dot (5th gen) deal — get it for $29.99 at Amazon
- Apple's iPhone 17 will come with a huge RAM upgrade, report claims
- 再接再厉 第三批标砖运抵宝兴
- Summit puts NK denuclearization back on track, eases cross
- 雨城区:前期工作基本就绪 22个项目月底前集中开工
- Bernie Sanders’ DNC speech sounded like everyone else’s. That’s astonishing.
- Tesla cuts prices of Model 3 and Model Y again
- Tottenham Hotspur name Jose Mourinho as manager
- Minor quake detected in North Korea; presumed to be natural
-
Top 10 Most Significant Nvidia GPUs of All Time
Founded in 1993, Nvidia is a youngster when compared to other semiconductor companies. However, its ...[详细] -
Target Circle Week is live — shop tons of deals, plus 15% off a one
UPDATE: Oct. 7, 2023, 3:00 a.m. EDT This story has been updated with the latest deals and shopping t ...[详细] -
North Korea has 'enough willingness' to talk with US, says delegation
President Moon Jae-in at the PyeonChang 2018 Winter Olympics' closing ceremony, Sunday. President of ...[详细] -
雅安日报讯 为迎接马年春节,汉源县唐家镇集贤村举办了乡村“春晚”。来自集贤村及附近村落的1000多名村民现场观看演出。该村负责人冉龙军介绍,提前准备的600根凳子在演出还没开始之前就被抢占一空,不少村 ...[详细]
-
Supercritical geothermal power: Limitless promise or impossible dream?
Supercritical geothermal power holds the promise of meeting humanity's energy needs for millions of ...[详细] -
巴蜀笑星媛凤和“矮冬瓜”表演川剧绝活“滚灯”巴蜀笑星“矮冬瓜”和芦山县思延乡村民互动雅安日报讯昨(25)日,由市委宣传部、四川广播电视台文艺广播、新闻资讯频道联合主办的“我的梦,中国梦——新春文化进万 ...[详细]
-
The next MacBook Pro models may get a battery life boost.
Your next MacBook Pro might have even better battery life than its predecessors. And that's huge con ...[详细] -
雅安日报讯 为迎接马年春节,汉源县唐家镇集贤村举办了乡村“春晚”。来自集贤村及附近村落的1000多名村民现场观看演出。该村负责人冉龙军介绍,提前准备的600根凳子在演出还没开始之前就被抢占一空,不少村 ...[详细]
-
Supercritical geothermal power: Limitless promise or impossible dream?
Supercritical geothermal power holds the promise of meeting humanity's energy needs for millions of ...[详细] -
近年来,不时有关于“黄连素可降血糖”的报道,甚至有人认为黄连素的降糖效果超过一般降糖药。黄连素(盐酸黄连素)的主要成分是小檗碱,是治疗胃肠炎、痢疾等病抗生素类药物。近年来,黄连素有降血糖作用被大量实验 ...[详细]
- How 3D Game Rendering Works: Texturing
- 'My life is in danger,' said NK leader's brother
- 16岁少年 带着父亲遗言 协助母亲撑起一个家
- 63 percent of Korean unwed mothers can’t afford medical treatment: study
- Pope says England are not 'one
- Tottenham Hotspur name Jose Mourinho as manager
- Twitter/X testing three new paid tiers in an effort to stop losing money