Why the nightmarish stalemate in Ukraine won’t end soon.
The largest war in Europe since World War II has become a slugfest. Russia is pulverizing Ukrainian cities with missiles and artillery; Ukraine is slamming Russian tanks and supply lines with drones and small arms. Tens of thousands are likely dead on both sides. But that doesn’t mean the fight is grinding to a halt. To the contrary, the rubble and bloodshed are likely to thicken in the coming days and weeks.
For here is the gruesome fact: The commanders and combatants on each side have reason to believe that, if they hold out a little bit longer, the other side will collapse—and thus they can gain a few more concessions, and tout something resembling a victory, when they both tumble, exhausted, to negotiate the terms of peace.
Each side probably does have a breaking point. The Ukrainians figure that the Russian forces—many of them marooned and thinly stretched—will eventually run out of food, ammunition, and other supplies, without which they can no longer fight. Meanwhile, the Russians figure that the Ukrainian resistance will eventually run out of steam, cities will fold, and the besieged government in Kyiv will surrender.
This phase of the war is basically a race to see which side crumbles first. Ukrainian generals guess that the Russian troops could run out of supplies by the end of this week. A pending new round of arms deliveries for Ukraine—including the $800 million worth of new weapons announced last week by U.S. President Joe Biden—should refresh the resistance for some time.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementYet the massive outflow of refugees, the savage killings of civilians, the endless bombing and shelling, and the prospect of more troops moving from Russia’s eastern regions toward the war zone must be taking their toll on Ukrainian citizens too.
No one knows how many people—civilian and military—have been killed so far. On Monday, the Moscow newspaper Komsomolskaya Pravda quoted the Russian ministry of defense as saying that 9,861 Russian servicemen had been killed and 16,153 wounded in the three weeks that this war has been slogging on. By comparison, Russia lost 15,000 troops in its decade-long war in Afghanistan.
However, the newspaper swiftly issued a statement that this was false information loaded on the news site by a hacker—an explanation that only raised more questions. (For instance, if there really was a hacker, was the information they inserted real, or disinformation designed to demoralize Russian readers?) The Ukrainian government claims 15,000 Russians have been killed already. U.S. intelligence puts the number around 7,000. Nobody really knows.
AdvertisementStill, whatever the precise numbers, an abundance of verified data—photos, iPhone footage, satellite imagery, and so forth—reveals, all too clearly, that the level of death and destruction on both sides has been staggeringly high.
AdvertisementIt’s unclear how long this can go on. Yet it’s still less clear who can stop it. There is no overriding entity that can step in, knock heads together, enforce a cease-fire, then impose or moderate a political settlement. The United Nations was created to do this sort of thing, but even if it had sufficiently large peacekeeping forces (which it doesn’t), Russia is one of the five permanentmembers of the U.N. Security Council, so it couldn’t be a neutral party.
Advertisement AdvertisementNor are there any countries with sufficient power and leverage to fill this role in the same way that, say, President Jimmy Carter corralled the leaders of Egypt and Israel into peace talks at Camp David in 1978. Maybe if President Biden andChina’s Xi Jinping jointly imposed a deal on Russia’s Vladimir Putin and Ukraine’s Volodymyr Zelensky, something would come of it—but first, Biden and Xi would have to get on the same page, and that seems a long way from happening.
Popular in News & Politics
- America Needs to Grow Up
- The Horrible Truth About Shaken Baby Syndrome Cases
- The Degradation of Donald Trump Attorney Todd Blanche Is Already Complete
- We Can Learn a Lot From the Weird Crew That Keeps Showing Up to Trump’s Trial
Meanwhile, neither side is ready to surrender. Zelensky has said he is open to direct talks with Putin. Earlier this week, Putin outlined a four-point peace plan, but it wasn’t serious. It called for Ukraine to give up plans to join NATO, acknowledge Russian ownership of Crimea, demilitarize, and denazify. Zelensky has already offered to drop his dream of joining NATO (a significant concession); Crimea might be an issue for realistic negotiation; but Putin’s two other demands are nonstarters. Demilitarizing would mean removing all Western-supplied weapons, which might have been an interesting item to discuss before Putin’s invasion, but it’s a nonstarter now. And since Putin claims that Kyiv is run by Nazis, denazification would mean the removal of Zelensky and his government from power—and that isn’t happening either.
Maybe this war will come to a sudden halt if Russia’s troops run out of gas or the Ukrainian resistance loses its will. For now, both sides seem to be settling in for a long and violent grind.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:行业动态)
- Update your BIOS: Utilities from Top Motherboard Makers
- Singapore GP gets green light
- “90后”到底在挑什么?
- NK hails its pandemic response as greatest achievement this year
- Republicans on abortion
- 11 Unique Amaros and Liqueurs to Level Up Your Aperol Spritz
- 全面打响“中国黄果柑第一县”品牌
- 我市7个参评县区进入“天府旅游名县”申报范围
- Hurricane Michael death toll rises again.
- Flying spaghetti monster and unworldly life filmed in deep sea footage
- 推广新能源车先考虑电池处置
- 40天春运结束 我市客车安全运送旅客148.17万人次
- Cool guy Mayor Bill de Blasio confesses his love for ska
-
21 College and University Museums
University campuses have no shortage of knowledge—from eclectic libraries filled to the brim with ra ...[详细] -
Lee registers as preliminary presidential candidate
Democratic Party Reps. Park Hong-keun (L) and Park Chan-dae (C) submit papers to register DP preside ...[详细] -
Ministry of EducationSouth Korea will fully resume in-person school classes next month in line with ...[详细]
-
Tesla's Cybertruck is already selling big, according to Elon Musk
Yes, Tesla's newly announced Cybertruck looks more like an old Apple mouse than it does an automobil ...[详细] -
Haider all set for Paralympics Ceremony
PARIS:Pakistan's premier athlete at the Paralympics Haider Ali will be representing the country ...[详细] -
NK hails its pandemic response as greatest achievement this year
North Korean leader Kim Jong-un greeting participants at a national meeting to declare victory in th ...[详细] -
Australian Open fans given 'Where is Peng Shuai?' shirts
MELBOURNE:Activists handed out 1,000 "Where is Peng Shuai?" T-shirts to spectators ahead o ...[详细] -
Jake Paul's attempt at calling out 'cyberbully' Cody Ko backfired beautifully
Jake Paul, a 22-year-old millionaire who built a career out of peddling merch to children and being ...[详细] -
7 Reasons to Explore Boston’s Lesser
Boston is brimming with popular and important historic sites, from Faneuil Hall and Boston Common to ...[详细] -
Twitter introduced Fleets and there's a real love/hate reaction online
Fleets, effectively Twitter's version of Instagram and Snapchat Stories, rolled out on Tuesday. The ...[详细]