Twitter is better than police at predicting riots, and it's unsettling
If you always kind of thought that Twitter is faster than authorities in accurately identifying threats, you're not that far from the truth.
SEE ALSO:Twitter cuts ties with another social media surveillance companyNew research from Cardiff University, which analysed 1.6 million tweets from the London 2011 riots, has noticed that the micro-blogging platform can be used to detect dangerous situations up to an hour faster than police reports.
To do so, researchers created event detection algorithms that use various features of Twitter data -- like sentiment, frequency of tweets containing certain words, and geolocation and timing of the tweets -- to cluster "similar" content and produce interpretable summaries.
Each cluster has variables like location, time sent, and hashtags used, and was given a timestamp.
"They [the algorithms] work by moving a sliding time window over the clusters so the content changes over time, enabling us to detect events over short periods," Dr. Pete Burnap, a Cardiff University researcher and co-author of the paper, said.
Surprisingly, perhaps, researchers discovered they were able to map out real-time disruptive events from five minutes to an hour before the Met Police were aware of them.
This example, during the incidents in Enfield Borough on Aug. 7, 2011, shows that the tweet about a fire and window-smashing in the area came more than one hour before the police report (the research paper contains only the content of the tweet to protect the individual's privacy):
Tweet may have been deletedCredit: cardiff university
Barnap argues this prediction element could be used to help first responders and emergency services before the threat escalates.
"We argue that people are starting to self report incidents that they witness via social media quicker than people are phoning 999 in some cases, so in being able to cluster and summarise these self-reports we can augment traditional event detection methods so help the policing services," he said.
"Police are having to do the same or more in terms of event management, but on a decreasing budget."
A 'Minority Report' scenario?
However, there is an argument that "predicting" some kind of activity before it escalates could lead to a Minority Report-kind of scenario, in which law enforcement intervenes to curb freedoms of assembly or interfere with freedom of speech.
Last year, Twitter shut off commercial access to social media surveillance company Geofeedia after the ACLU revealed that Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram data was being marketed by Geofeedia to police as a way to monitor activists and protests.
"People are starting to self report incidents that they witness via social media quicker than people are phoning 999 in some cases."
The company told police they could track hashtags associated with Black Lives Matter protests, even using facial recognition software in real time.
Other surveillance programs include Beware, which markets itself as a service that can create "awareness of potential threats" and can assign a "threat level" to a social media user.
Media Sonar, whose website says it has "proven" to be a "powerful tool for assessing threats," was found to market their services to the Fresno Police Department, according to results of an investigation by the ACLU published in December 2015.
Protecting privacy
Burnap recognises social media could be used to invade people's privacy and crack down on dissent.
"There must be stringent ethical practices in place to avoid this," he said, noting that his research works at an aggregate level, not pinpointing any specific Twitter users like Geofeedia and others did.
"Our research works at an aggregate level so really only flags events once there is sufficient ‘noise’ around a certain event," he says.
"This works in two ways -- firstly by avoiding identifying individuals in a effort to retain privacy, and also in that it requires effort and collusion to create fake reports as we’re not dependent on taking a single report as evidence of an event."
For instance, the research paper doesn't identify the individuals behind the tweets (Mashablewas able to uncover it using Twitter search).
The research could allow online observations of offline events, enabling better insights into public reports of disruptive events, Burnap says.
"The idea is that this research could augment more traditional approaches to event detection and sit alongside those traditional practices," he says.
So we're not in Minority Reportterritory, yet, but surely authorities are taking note. You've been warned.
Featured Video For You
(责任编辑:产品中心)
- The AI stock bubble has burst. Here's how we know.
- Don Jr. thinks 'S&L' is short for 'Saturday Night Live'
- 'The Office' stars recall the one word Steve Carell said that made everyone break
- Don Jr. thinks 'S&L' is short for 'Saturday Night Live'
- Bernie Sanders’ DNC speech sounded like everyone else’s. That’s astonishing.
- Abrar Ahmed returns as Pakistan names squad for second Test against Bangladesh
- [Seoul Struggles 11] Do I have to detour again to avoid the protest?
- Twitter updates lists as it pushes users toward 'interests'
- Don Jr. thinks 'S&L' is short for 'Saturday Night Live'
- Haider all set for Paralympics Ceremony
- Corn Twitter comes for Bud Light after their anti
- Facebook's role in child sex abuse online raises troubling questions
- 城乡面貌焕然一新 40年发展日新月异
-
Families of S. Korean detainees in NK appeal to embassies for support
Lee Shin-wha, former ambassador for international cooperation on North Korean human rights (center), ...[详细] -
凭“食力”圈粉!连州菜心在武汉街头受热捧 | 连州菜心万里行④_南方+_南方plus“这个菜心看起来真好!”“这个菜心和我之前吃的不太一样,颜值还很高!”“可以把装菜心的箱子也给我吗?我看到上面有联系 ...[详细]
-
抢先看!粤西冬种近400个樱桃番茄品种打擂台_南方+_南方plus冬日的阳光洒满大地照耀着整齐有序的番茄田园黄色、红色、绿色各色樱桃番茄在阳光下仿佛一串串诱人的小宝石等待着被人发掘1月4日茂名市电白区 ...[详细]
-
Department of Education considers letting schools buy guns for teachers with federal grant funds.
A quick update on America’s plunge into gun-strapped dystopia.The New York Timesreported on Tuesday ...[详细] -
Swifties for Kamala raises over $100,000 in donations for Harris campaign
An estimated 27,000 Swifties gathered last night, not for the Eras Tour, but to rally for the electi ...[详细] -
US conveyed concerns over N. Korean nuclear weapon test to China
U.S. national security adviser Jake Sullivan holds a news briefing about the situation in Afghanista ...[详细] -
One of the problems with our ongoing shift toward renewable energy relates to the way we store it, w ...[详细]
-
Surreal memes deserve their own internet dimension
In November, the surreal meme creator @surrealvault decided to shutter her merch shop, which had exi ...[详细] -
Echo Dot (5th gen) deal — get it for $29.99 at Amazon
GET $20 OFF:As of Aug. 23, you can get an Echo Dot (5th gen) for $29.99 at Amazon, down from $49.99. ...[详细] -
25 good tweets for people who hate Valentine's Day
Valentine's Day is kind of nice, but it's mostly a cloying, capitalist nightmare. It makes sense, th ...[详细]
Alcaraz vs. Van de Zandschulp 2024 livestream: Watch US Open for free
Twitter updates lists as it pushes users toward 'interests'
- Slot extends perfect Liverpool start
- 花城论花,专家共话花卉创新发展
- Randolph County, Georgia, rejects plan to close polls before the November election.
- These are all the Echo speakers Amazon showed off at its big event
- Apple's iPhone 17 will come with a huge RAM upgrade, report claims
- We're getting a period emoji and it's bloody brilliant news
- Andrew Gillum Florida: Bernie Sanders' endorsee wins Democratic primary over Gwen Graham.