United States v. Haymond: Gorsuch and Sotomayor defend Sixth Amendment right to a jury trial.
Popular in News & Politics
- Seriously, Congress Has Been Even More Embarrassing Than Usual Lately
- Evidence Is Building That Samuel Alito’s Brain Is Filled to the Brim With Right-Wing Internet Chum
- Why Netanyahu’s War Cabinet Is Existentially Divided
- Rudy Giuliani Gets Quite the Birthday Present!
In 2002, Justice Antonin Scalia warned that “our people’s traditional belief in the right of trial by jury is in perilous decline.” His successor, Justice Neil Gorsuch, agrees—and he isn’t happy about it. On Tuesday, during oral arguments in United States v. Haymond, Gorsuch lambasted Congress’ efforts to skirt the Constitution by empowering judges to imprison sex offenders without the safeguard of a jury. It was a remarkable defense of the Sixth Amendment that points toward a broad decision restoring the jury trial right to some of the country’s most maligned defendants.
Haymond involves a federal statute that governs sentencing for certain defendants convicted of a sex offense. After completing their prison term, these offenders are placed on supervised release. If offenders violate the terms of their release, a judge can send them back to prison to serve more time for their original conviction. That’s standard practice in the federal system. The statute at issue in Haymond, though, is a different beast. Under this law, a judge must sentence offenders to additional prison time—from five years to life—if they violate the terms of their release. This new sentence may go beyond what the offender’s first conviction allowed. And the judge need only find proof of a violation “by a preponderance of the evidence.” No jury is involved.
This scheme is, to put it mildly, quite weird. Generally, under the Fifth and Sixth Amendments, the government must prove every element of a crime that increases a sentence to a jury, beyond a reasonable doubt. The law in Haymond flips this requirement on its head. It allows a judge to decide the facts herself, under a standard more lenient than the Due Process Clause typically requires. And once she has found the offender guilty, she can imprison him for much longer than his original conviction permitted.
AdvertisementOn Tuesday, Gorsuch sounded downright shocked by this flagrant infringement of the Sixth Amendment. “Why is the government so anxious to avoid having the involvement of citizens in this process?” he asked Eric Feigin, assistant to the Solicitor General. “It would be a rather simple thing to convene a jury, wouldn’t it?
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement“Historically,” Gorsuch continued, “there’s never been this kind of system before. Congress self-consciously created this system. And I guess … I’m just struggling. I just don’t understand why the government resists the involvement of a jury of a man’s or woman’s peers.”
Gorsuch seemed rankled by the fact that Congress abolished parole for federal defendants, then sought to replace it with a draconian scheme like this one. Instead of parole, sex offenders now receive supervised release—but if they’re accused of a new misdeed, they lose their right to a jury trial. And if they’re found guilty (by a judge), they may be locked up for life. “We had parole systems previously,” Gorsuch said, “and Congress chose to abandon that system. And why doesn’t that choice have consequences? And why isn’t one of those consequences the jury right?”
AdvertisementAs usual, Justice Sonia Sotomayor was right at Gorsuch side defending the Sixth Amendment. “Is there any other area of the law in which we permit imprisonment by a preponderance of the evidence?” Sotomayor asked Feigin. “I’m trying to figure out why a judge now gets to … find by a preponderance of the evidence, after you’ve been sentenced to the five years, that we really should have given you eight years.” If “a jury didn’t find facts sufficient to give him the additional years,” how can that sentence possibly be constitutional?
AdvertisementThe answer is that it isn’t. And on Tuesday, a clear majority of the court seemed prepared to rule as much, either striking down the scheme altogether or compelling the government to prove each new offense to a jury, beyond a reasonable doubt. That would be an important victory for the Sixth Amendment, and an affirmation that the government cannot lock away sex offenders for life without a jury’s input. True, it might make prosecutors’ jobs a bit more difficult. As Scalia wrote in 2003, however, the jury trial “has never been efficient”—but “it has always been free.”
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:行业动态)
- 抖音超600万次传播量!广东省农事运动会乡村直播大赛火出圈
- 高永川:让更多人记住蒙顶山茶
- Radiohead launches online 'public library' so you can stream their rare stuff
- Samsung unveils 'Instagram mode' for Galaxy S10 camera
- [From the Scene] How ‘world’s first oil town’ is wrestling to become ‘green'
- Carbon neutrality law violates basic rights: Constitutional Court
- Unification minister vows continued efforts for 'meaningful' change in inter
- Coronavirus self
- Coronavirus self
- US Open 2024 livestream: How to watch US Open tennis for free
- 养成良好生活习惯 远离疾病一身轻松
- [Newsmaker] Local official indicted for land speculation in 1st for govt. task force
- Number of foreign visitors dips 10.7% in March
-
Trump trials: Jack Smith is reportedly reconsidering his strategy.
Donald Trump has been convicted of 34 felony counts in the New York hush money case—but there’s a le ...[详细] -
It’s time for the U.S. to have a conversation about its overseas territories.
It’s been six months since Hurricanes Irma and Maria hit Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands in ...[详细] -
Diaz stunner gives Colombia third Copa place
BRASILIA:Luis Diaz scored a sensational winner with virtually the last kick of the match as Colombia ...[详细] -
百千万种“丰”采如斯“湛”放 | 乡村行 看振兴_南方+_南方plus在遂溪县草潭镇的金鲳鱼深海网箱养殖基地,随着起重臂缓缓升起,一网网活蹦乱跳的金鲳鱼被装入运输船。眼下正是一年一度金鲳鱼上市旺季,每 ...[详细]
-
Who is the Dark Wizard in 'The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power' Season 2?
Just when The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Powerreveals the identity of one mysterious wizard, it ...[详细] -
不到2岁的女孩周菲化名)同家人一起过交叉路口时,被左转弯小车撞上,包括周菲在内的3人受伤。周菲出院后不久,其监护人向法院提起诉讼,要求驾驶员、车主,以及车辆投保的保险公司支付住院75天的伙食费、护理费 ...[详细]
-
North Korea shows off new ICBMs at parade
North Korea's military showcases a new intercontinental ballistic missile during a parade in Pyongya ...[详细] -
Magic Leap's 'Magicverse' could be a glimpse of our 5G future
Tech optimism can be hard to come by these days. But the idea that tech will empower us to make the ...[详细] -
Top 10 Most Significant Nvidia GPUs of All Time
Founded in 1993, Nvidia is a youngster when compared to other semiconductor companies. However, its ...[详细] -
Samsung unveils 'Instagram mode' for Galaxy S10 camera
Because everyone definitely wants some Facebook-affiliated software pre-installed on their smartphon ...[详细]
How do you make safe, cheap nuclear reactors? Bury them a mile deep
Portion of cyberbullying sharply increases as pandemic turns classes online: survey
- Yoon, US Senate's armed service committee chief discuss alliance, N.K. threats
- 江门这场盛会,为啥那么令人期待?
- 预计2024年底完工,全球首创水体自然交换型养殖工船“九洲一号”在珠海开建
- Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner spent $130 for each primary vote he got Tuesday.
- Foreign, multicultural students rise amid declining school population
- Combined forces of S. Korea, US fully ready to deter N. Korean threats: Milley
- It’s time for the U.S. to have a conversation about its overseas territories.