Elizabeth Warren knows how to attack Donald Trump. Why doesn’t Hillary Clinton?
One thing that the expensive, experienced consultants running Hillary Clinton’s campaign must love about their jobs is all the pundits lecturing them about how they need to settle on a master narrative defining Donald Trump. This is a thought that never occurred to them, and they appreciate everyone instructing them on this basic concept of political messaging.
They get it. But that doesn’t mean they’ve figured it out.
They have to decide what role Donald Trump is going to play in the story they write about him, much as the Obama campaign in 2012 had to decide what Mitt Romney was going to be—or much as Trump has already decided what Hillary is going to be (“Crooked Hillary”). There was a debate early in the 2012 Obama campaign about whether to depict Romney as a conviction-free, flip-flopping opportunist or an evil plutocrat feasting on the bone marrow of the proletariat. They went the C. Montgomery Burns path and synced all of their tactics accordingly. It won them another four years. (And who supposedly helped them settle on rich monster over flip-flopper? Bill Clinton.)
Just because the Clinton people know they have to tell a story about Donald Trump, though, doesn’t mean such a story easily presents itself. There are so many options they don’t know where to begin. Romney could be cut pretty easily into the two archetypes of opportunist or plutocrat. With Trump, you have: opportunist, plutocrat, racist demagogue, sexist pig, business fraud, narcissist, clown who is completely unfit for the presidency both in terms of knowledge and temperament, and asshole. Which should the Clinton campaign go with?
AdvertisementTheWashington Poston Wednesday came out with the big reveal about the Clinton campaign’s plan. If you haven’t already placed your bets, do so now before reading any further.
Clinton’s aides say they have settled on the big story they want to tell about Trump: He is a business fraud who has cheated working people for his own gain, and his ideas, temperament and moves to marginalize people by race, gender and creed make him simply unacceptable as commander in chief.Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement
So they have whittled down the bountiful list of master narratives to … everything. Clinton people! When they say you have to fit your story into a single sentence, that doesn’t mean it can be a run-on sentence with clauses and nested lists and dormer windows and a carport and all.
AdvertisementIt could be that the Clintonistas’ inability to settle on an overarching story about Trump is a reflection of their inability to settle on an overarching story about themselves.
As the Post’s Greg Sargent asks, what is Hillary Clinton’s affirmative master narrative for Hillary Clinton? There are a lot of substories floating around that haven’t congealed into an uber-story: a fighter, an advocate for women and children, a sturdy hand, an experienced leader. What does this add up to? It will be plenty easier for Clinton and Co. to settle on what they want Trump to be once they’ve figured out what they themselves are.
Take, by contrast, the example of another prominent Democratic voice who knows exactly what she is. Sen. Elizabeth Warren believes that Wall Street and other large corporations have rigged the economy to screw you over. Observe, then, the felicity with which this sense of purpose allows her to tear into Trump as she did at a gala Tuesday night.
Advertisement Advertisement“Donald Trump was drooling over the idea of a housing meltdown because it meant he could buy up more property on the cheap,” Warren said, touching on one of the more meaningful Trump opposition sound bites to emerge recently.
Advertisement“What kind of a man does that? What kind of a man roots for people to get thrown out of their house? What kind of a man roots for people to get thrown out of their jobs? To root for people to lose their pensions? To root for two little girls in Clark County, Nevada, to end up living out of a van?Advertisement Advertisement
“What kind of a man does that? I’ll tell you exactly what kind of a man does that: It is a man who cares about no one but himself. A small, insecure moneygrubber who doesn’t care who gets hurt so long as he makes a profit off it. What kind of man does that? A man who will never be president of the United States.”Advertisement
She then lit into him for wanting to eliminate the Dodd–Frank financial reform law, something he has always said he would do but which the political world has only recently seemed to notice: “Donald Trump is worried about helping poor little Wall Street? Let me find the world’s smallest violin to play a sad, sad song.”
Trump later responded by calling Warren “Pocahontas,” as he does.
Elizabeth Warren and Hillary Clinton are very different politicians. Warren specializes in financial reform and corporate abuse, while Clinton, by nature of the job she seeks, has to represent the various constituencies that make up the Democratic coalition, and thus doesn’t have the luxury of being narrow in her attacks. Or something like that. What’s motivating Clinton to run for president beyond her belief that she has the appropriate skillset and experience to manage the federal government? If there issomething else, it really hasn’t been communicated well. If she can change that, then defining Donald Trump will come naturally—and be an afterthought.
Read more Slate coverage of the 2016 campaign.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:行业动态)
- The Techies Who Lunch
- At last: Cincinnati title lands Medvedev in world top five
- 院士领衔,聚焦前沿!2023水产种业高质量发展论坛亮点抢先看
- At last: Cincinnati title lands Medvedev in world top five
- 尝“鲜”盛宴,等你来探!2024年清远西牛麻竹笋尝鲜季即将启幕
- NYT mini crossword answers for August 29
- Trump's top environment pick made some bonkers climate science claims
- 全力打造“生态极” 实现雅安绿色崛起
- Apparently Drake is just as obsessed with 'Harry Potter' as you are
- Trump won't stop making a deceptive bird claim. Experts debunk it.
- How to use all of iOS 16's new features
- 省医保局对我市监管人员进行监管业务培训
- 我市全面实现生育服务网络办理
-
Kamala Harris’ ridiculous problem with the political press.
Last Thursday, standing on the tarmac in Michigan in front of Air Force Two, Kamala Harris took some ...[详细] -
Killings by police ramp up in Rio ahead of Olympics
Police in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, have killed at least 11 people so far in April, according to Amnes ...[详细] -
Illinois police rescue plump raccoon that was too big for sewer grate
Some days are good: you feel powerful, happy -- like there's nothing on this planet that you can't d ...[详细] -
Brian Michael Bendis just moved from Marvel to DC Comics
Brian Michael Bendis has been working with Marvel for the better part of 20 years. He built its well ...[详细] -
14 Heists, Robberies, and Other Great Capers
In the dark hours of the morning on Monday, November 25, 2019, five masked men broke into the Green ...[详细] -
Twitter's search tool is blocking photo searches of 'bisexual'
Twitter has a lot of explaining to do. The social media platform is under scrutiny after several acc ...[详细] -
为进一步提高对“两定”机构医保医疗服务的监督管理水平,确保基金安全,6月14日,省医保局医疗保险监督管理室主任张志宏专程到雅对全市医保监管人员进行业务培训。张志宏主任用自己多年从事对定点医院监管积淀下 ...[详细]
-
还是在原来的土地上干同样的活,村民们的身份已经变成了上班族早上八点半上班,中午休息一小时,下午六点下班,工资按月结算,法定假日照样放假。汉源县晒经乡晒经村有这样一帮“上班族”农民。16日,记者走进晒经 ...[详细]
-
雅州利剑集中攻坚执行大会战专项行动启动走进位于青衣江畔雨城区三雅路6号的雅安市中级人民法院,办公环境窗明几净,法院干警热情服务……一缕缕文明新风扑面而来。文明的厚度,决定发展的高度。2018年,获“四 ...[详细]
-
雅安日报讯近日,记者从市政建设工程公司获悉,我市通过创新工作方法,在市区育才路、挺进路、康藏路等路段改建部分绿化带,增设了64个摩托车、电动车和自行车停车点,进一步缓解了市区机动车和非机动车停车难现象 ...[详细]
11 Unique Amaros and Liqueurs to Level Up Your Aperol Spritz
Another Kevin Spacey project booted amid sexual assault allegations
- Nvidia GeForce Now Ultimate vs. New Graphics Card
- Man booked on string of claw machine robberies
- 朗行到店 火爆销售中
- 16 best uses of 280 characters on Twitter
- 13 Astronomical Clocks Connecting Time And Space
- South Korea issues arrest warrant for Do Kwon, founder of failed stablecoin Terra
- Party floor leaders to continue talks on normalizing parliament