Obama's statement on immigration leaves a bit to be desired
Former President Barack Obama finally weighed in on the ongoing debate over the separation of migrant children from their families at the U.S.-Mexico border, and it left a little to be desired for a few reasons.
SEE ALSO:Michelle Obama joins Laura Bush in taking on Trump's immigration policyIn a post to Facebook Wednesday afternoon to mark World Refugee Day, Obama lamented, "And to watch those families broken apart in real time puts to us a very simple question: are we a nation that accepts the cruelty of ripping children from their parents’ arms, or are we a nation that values families, and works to keep them together?"
It's an eloquent explanation of everything that's wrong with the current administration's approach to immigration, but it stops short of a full-throated condemnation, choosing instead to offer more of a "this is how it should be" argument.
While it's traditionally unusual for a former president to weigh in on the current administration's policies and actions, these are unusual times. Obama has done so on a few occasions, criticizing Trump's action on policies that he helped create, like the Iran Nuclear Deal, the Affordable Care Act, and the Paris Climate Agreement.
Another reason Obama may not have offered a totally damning condemnation of Trump's immigration policy is that his administration had its own checkered policy approach on the subject.
SEE ALSO:7 activist groups supporting families at the border that need your help right nowFirst, though, it is important to note that the Trump administration's assertion that the family separation policy was utilized by Obama is a lie. As NBC News outlines, the separations were never enacted as policy and in the instances where it did occur, it was remedied quickly.
Additionally, Sarah Pierce, a policy analyst at the Migration Policy Institute, told the Washington Post:
“Our understanding is that generally parents were not prosecuted for illegal entry under President Obama. There may have been some separation if there was suspicion that the children were being trafficked or a claimed parent-child relationship did not actually exist. But nothing like the levels we are seeing today.”
The Obama administration also fought hard for amnesty for undocumented immigrants (via the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) executive order), but some efforts have been undone by the Supreme Court, and Trump is continuing efforts to repeal DACA.
But the Obama administration diduse the detention of families in an effort to deter other undocumented migrants from crossing the border in 2014 and 2015, when there was a surge of such crossings, a move that was derided by many at the time.
The courts intervened, though, saying the policy violated a pair of court cases that set the standards and length of times undocumented migrant families could be detained, and they had to be released after a set amount time while they awaited immigration hearings.
The process was called "catch and release" and dated back to the George W. Bush administration, but is often (incorrectly) associated with Obama because of those battle with the courts. Trump ended this practice in 2018 in an effort to crack down on undocumented migrants.
The Obama administration also faced harsh criticism from immigration rights activists and officials for its high number of deportations -- the most of any president so far. The Obama administration focused primarily on undocumented migrants who had a criminal history, but the overall high number and criticism from activists have lingered.
None of this equates Obama's immigration policy (which had plenty of positive elements along with those that were criticized) with that of Trump's heinous, inhumane approach. But it does go a way to explaining why Obama is soft-pedaling his criticism of Trump in this instance when previously he has been more forthright.
Unlike Trump, Obama seems self-aware of his legacy on immigration and is seeking not the inflame that critique further. Though there may come a time when Obama supporters and those who oppose Trump's policy call on the 44th president to say and do more, his previous stances be damned.
(责任编辑:关于我们)
- Aricell CEO arrested in first case under industrial accidents law
- Campbell highlights Washington Declaration amid security concerns over Putin
- The Techies Who Lunch
- Ruling bloc divided on foreign nannies' pay
- 9 Planetariums to Get Lost in the Cosmos
- Best smart home deal: The Amazon Smart Thermostat is just $63.99
- 21 College and University Museums
- Anatomy of a Keyboard
- 21 Lost and Lonely Cemeteries
- Yoon, US Senate's armed service committee chief discuss alliance, N.K. threats
- A Journey Into the Mind of Stephen King
- 23 Peculiar Places of 2023
- Cicadas love to land on people. Experts explain why.
-
China's Tsinghua University has scored a world first by demonstrating the inherent safety of the fir ...[详细]
-
Newborns hit new low, but births to those unmarried reach record high: data
(Getty Images)Births to those not married accounted for nearly 5 percent of all births last year, se ...[详细] -
Scientists discover where the huge dinosaur
A menacing asteroid, some six miles wide, triggered Earth's last mass extinction. Now, scientists ha ...[详细] -
现场观众驻足欣赏精美的蒙山窑瓷器用名山土,烧蒙山器,泡蒙山茶。8月24日,蒙山窑艺术馆开馆仪式在蒙顶山4A级旅游景区举行,一大批采用蒙顶山优质高岭土烧制的蒙山窑瓷器惊艳亮相,吸引了不少瓷器爱好者及游客 ...[详细]
-
阳江村K开麦,阳西3人晋级!| 2024广东乡村歌手大赛_南方+_南方plus8月20日晚,2024广东乡村歌手大赛阳江赛区正式开启。首场赛事在阳西县的“文化地标”——阳西县文化馆演艺厅拉开序幕。演艺 ...[详细]
-
21 Unexpected Wonders in Colorado’s Vibrant Cities and Small Towns
Between Colorado’s storied ranges, folded into its valleys and sprinkled across its plains, you’ll f ...[详细] -
A Journey Into the Mind of Stephen King
Perhaps no other author has induced more childhood nightmares and spine-tingling reads than the lege ...[详细] -
[From the Scene] How ‘world’s first oil town’ is wrestling to become ‘green'
City of Baku, Azerbaijan (Getty Imgage)BAKU, Azerbaijan -- Driving just a few miles from the venue o ...[详细] -
With more ballot initiatives ready to go before voters, supporters of reproductive rights are hoping ...[详细]
-
味道真系正!怀集食材邂逅顺德厨艺_南方+_南方plus借顺德区举办第46届国际龙家具展览会和第36届亚洲国际家具材料博览会之机,8月19日,怀集县联合顺德区在龙江镇S-Park体育公园举办“怀集味道· ...[详细]
- Update your BIOS: Utilities from Top Motherboard Makers
- 24 Museums Dedicated to Black History
- Yoon, US Senate's armed service committee chief discuss alliance, N.K. threats
- 21 Unexpected Wonders in Colorado’s Vibrant Cities and Small Towns
- Ruling bloc divided on foreign nannies' pay
- 10 Big Misconceptions About Computer Hardware
- PS5 Pro: There are new whispers that the release date is fast approaching