Ukraine NATO: Why it's not a good time for the country to join
Is it time for Ukraine to join NATO?
President Volodymyr Zelensky told a group of European leaders in Moldova on Thursday that he’s ready to enter the Western military alliance whenever they’re ready to have him. Ukraine’s former defense minister argues in Foreign Affairs that it should become a member “now.” Henry Kissinger, who once opposed the idea, now supports it as well. Finally, at a meeting this week in Oslo, NATO foreign ministers brought up the idea of Ukraine’s ascension and agreed to put it on the agenda for next month’s summit of NATO’s heads of state in Vilnius.
The Ukrainian army’s skill, valor, and success in repelling Moscow’s invasion certainly demonstrates that it can integrate fully with NATO’s weaponry, infrastructure, training, and tactics—one of the official requirements for admission to the alliance. In fact, it now stands as the strongest, most adept army in all of Europe.
However, there are other prerequisites that Ukraine has not satisfied, and some of them are far from trivial or merely technical matters. Let’s leave aside the requirement that a new NATO member must have a “functioning democratic political system based on a market economy” with minimal corruption—a shortfall for which Zelensky shouldn’t be penalized, given that he’s fighting a war for national survival.
But there are other requirements—laid out in an official 1995 study on NATO enlargement—that can’t be sidestepped. For instance, new members must have stable borders and display “a commitment to the peaceful resolution of conflicts.” It is hardly Ukraine’s fault that its borders are in violent contention and that a peaceful settlement, at least right now, would mean surrender. Still, NATO isa common-defense alliance, and at minimum its members need to know exactly what they’re promising to defend.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementRelated From Slate
Fred Kaplan
This Can’t Be Good for Putin
Read MoreNew members must also be able and willing “to make a military contribution to NATO operations.” Ukrainian soldiers are among the most capable on the continent, but they are preoccupied in their own war and thus unable to help other member-states, should they be attacked. Nor does the Kyiv government have a dime to spend on its own defense; it is entirely reliant on others for its weapons, training, and other aspects of the fight. Again, this is hardly Zelensky’s fault, but it is still a limiting factor.
There are two other considerations, apart from the formal admission requirements. First, if Ukraine joined NATO now, Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty (requiring members to treat an attack against one as an attack against all) would commit the United States and the other alliance members to join the war against Russia directly. This is what President Biden and the other leaders have carefully avoided, fearing that Vladimir Putin would respond by attacking the territory of NATO members, including perhaps the U.S. At tense moments in its 74-year history, the alliance has effectively deterredRussian aggression in Europe. But bringing Ukraine onboard would mean stepping into—and expanding the scope of—a war already in motion. And while the members are committed to helping Ukraine stave off Moscow’s invasion (to the tune of sending tens of billions of dollars in military aid), they aren’t so committed as to risk World War III.
AdvertisementPopular in News & Politics
- A Supreme Court Justice Gave Us Alarming New Evidence That He’s Living in MAGA World
- Ten Years Ago, His Book about Civilizational Collapse Got Unexpectedly Popular. He’s Back With a Little Bit of Hope.
- We’ve Been Entertaining an Illusion About the Supreme Court. It’s Finally Been Shattered.
- Them Supreme Court Boys Are at It Again
There is one final matter. If there ever are peace negotiations to end this war, Ukraine’s status within European institutions will likely be a point of discussion. To bring the country into NATO now would preempt membership’s value as a bargaining chip. For example, in settling the disposition of Crimea, one could imagine a deal where Russia controls the peninsula, in exchange for which Ukraine joins NATO (or Ukraine gets Crimea but can’t join NATO).
The Ukrainian people have demonstrated that they deserve a place in the West. At the very least, they deserve a set of security guarantees from several friendly nations, many of which happen to be NATO members. But those arguing for Ukraine’s instant admission to the alliance—on the premise that it will help Kyiv quickly win the war—are looking for easy, legalistic solutions to a hard political and military challenge. NATO membership probably will happen—and should happen—at some point. But for several institutional and practical reasons, now is not the time.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- This shark lives for centuries. Scientists discover how it resists aging.
- 我市主要农作物肥料配方
- NK plans to send weapons, munitions to Russia in exchange for food: US NSC
- CBS paid $9.5 million to 'Bull' actress Eliza Dushku over harassment claim
- [Exclusive] Samsung unsure of Suga's future as brand ambassador: source
- NYT Strands hints, answers for August 29
- N. Korea holds general meeting of Olympic Committee
- 您对保险行业满意吗?
- N. Korea holds general meeting of Olympic Committee
- 雨城区疾控中心提示:科学补碘 防治碘缺乏病
- S. Korea to use chartered flight to bring home about 80 citizens
- NK plans to send weapons, munitions to Russia in exchange for food: US NSC
- Gov't report reveals children, pregnant women executed, tortured in North Korea
-
本报讯8月23日,中国劳动关系学院劳动关系与人力资源学院副院长张才明一行赴雅考察职工思想政治引领数智化发展工作开展情况。中国劳动关系学院为中华全国总工会和教育部联合共建,是全国总工会唯一一所普通高等院 ...[详细]
-
N. Korea holds general meeting of Olympic Committee
North Korea holds a general assembly meeting of its Olympic Committee in 2022 in this undated file p ...[详细] -
Facebook's auto translation AI fail leads to a nightmare for a Palestinian man
Bad translations often make good comedy, but in the case of this Palestinian man, they marked the st ...[详细] -
Foldable smartphones that open up into tablets are destined to flop
Decades of sci-fi movies have conditioned us to lust after devices that are pure screen with no beze ...[详细] -
The vast majority of our portable electronic gadgets, and the new wave of electric transportation, a ...[详细]
-
'Mary Poppins Returns', but the magic's gone: Review
To ask why Mary Poppins Returnsexists would be to ask why Disney would want a license to print money ...[详细] -
Google Authenticator is a free security app that can protect your accounts against password theft. I ...[详细]
-
NK fires projectiles in second weapons test this month
Photos released by the Korean Central News Agency show projectiles being fired from a transporter-er ...[详细] -
8月26日,市委书记夏凤俭在雅与四川建安工业有限责任公司董事长耿海波一行座谈。双方分别介绍了雅安经济社会发展情况和企业生产经营情况,围绕推动企业科技创新、扩大投资布局、做强产业集群、开拓市场空间等方面 ...[详细]
-
This Instagram artist's mock self
How to make dysfunctional love last forever is a self-help book I'd personally be very, very interes ...[详细]