Obama’s legacy will be inspirational rather than transformational.
A decade ago, Barack Obama was already contemplating his presidential legacy. I know because I talked to him about it in 2006, during a long interview for a now-defunct men’s magazine. In a reflective mood after finishing his second book, his suit coat off and necktie loosened, the 44-year-old freshman senator opened up about his political ambition.
“My attitude about something like the presidency is that you don’t want to just bethe president,” he told me. “You want to change the country. You want to make a unique contribution. You want to be a great president.”
Obama described visiting the Washington Hilton and walking down a long corridor decorated with pictures of all America’s presidents. “You go through, and you think, who are these guys? There are, what, maybe 10 presidents in our history out of 40-something who you can truly say led the country? And then there are 30 who just kind of did their best. And so, I guess my point is, just being the president is not a good way of thinking about it.”
In his final days in office, I’ve been remembering the bar Obama set for himself that summer afternoon and wondering whether he feels that he cleared it. Will Obama be remembered as a top-10 president, one who changed the country? Or as one of the perhaps admirable but not-quite-transformational others?
During his race against Hillary Clinton in 2008, Obama articulated the same distinction in a way certain to annoy her and her husband by saying that “Ronald Reagan changed the trajectory of America in a way that, you know, Richard Nixon did not and in a way that Bill Clinton did not.” Obama aspired to be a kind of liberal Reagan who would not just change policy but embody the emergence of a diverse and progressive society.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementJonathan Chait’s provocative new book Audacity,hastily updated for Donald Trump’s unforeseen victory, makes the case that Obama’s substantive accomplishments are both momentous and likely to survive the authoritarian circus now arrived in town. Chait points to the president’s handling of the 2008 financial crisis, the passage of the Affordable Care Act, and the Paris Accord on greenhouse gas reduction, as well as less heralded changes around education, financial regulation, and economic distribution.
Chait’s case about the significance of Obama’s achievements is more convincing than his prediction about their durability. After votes in the House and Senate last week, Obamacare appears to be headed for straight-up repeal rather than face-saving modification. During the campaign, Obama said that if Trump were to be elected, eight years of accomplishment would go out the window. Afterward, Obama put it rather differently, telling David Remnick of theNew Yorker that he had done “seventy or seventy-five per cent” of what he intended. “Maybe fifteen per cent of that gets rolled back, twenty per cent, but there’s still a lot of stuff that sticks.”
AdvertisementAlas, the earlier warning looks more accurate. But whether universal health insurance survives in some form, the larger question is the one Obama pointed to in his comments contrasting Reagan with Clinton. “Reagan put us on a fundamentally different path because the country was ready for it,” he said. To count as transformative, a president needs to synthesize the moment and mood of the country. Where Reagan channeled disenchantment with overweening government, Obama symbolized America’s transformation into a multiracial country.
AdvertisementThat demographic change is inevitable, but Obama was a precocious avatar. America remains 62 percent white, according to the Census Bureau. Not until mid-century will minorities become the majority. As Chait persuasively argues, the headwinds Obama faced were mostly racial blowback. In many cases, Republican politicians and white voters abandoned policies they had long supported once they were endorsed by a black president.
Advertisement AdvertisementGiven the racially tinged opposition he faced, it’s hard to make the case that Obama could have accomplished a great deal more either by being tougher or more gentle. Yet for someone who saw himself as a political bridge, the inability to produce any durable consensus must count as a tremendous disappointment. His faith in transcending partisanship, in the face of all evidence, stands as both inspirational and somewhat naïve. Obama called his pre-presidential book TheAudacity of Hope.His post-presidential might be titled The Triumph of Hope Over Experience.
Ten years ago, Obama told me that establishing universal health care should be his party’s highest priority and that he worried about the lack of economic opportunity driving racial polarization. Listening to the powerful farewell address he delivered in Chicago last week, I was struck the remarkable consistency of his views and his approach. Despite the ways in which his worst fears have been borne out, he has remained rock steady in his calm application of reason, his respect for opponents who haven’t much respected him, and his methodical pursuit of common ground. Obama’s absence of bitterness is remarkable. He leaves a legacy of integrity, eloquence, and patient commitment in this dark hour of American politics.
___
A slightly different version of this piece appears in theFinancial Times.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- NYT Strands hints, answers for August 29
- Donald Trump refuses to be a gracious winner
- 广州统一战线助力“百千万工程”落地见效
- Facebook makes smallest necessary change to race
- I went to an offline dating event for singles. Here's how it went.
- Best CPU Deals, AMD vs Intel: Holiday CPU Buying Guide
- Heat damage still haunts North Korea
- 国道318线多营至飞仙关段主体工程基本完工
- South Korean train travels to the North for joint railway inspection [PHOTOS]
- [Exclusive] Samsung unsure of Suga's future as brand ambassador: source
- World No.1 Scheffler wins first major at Masters
- WhatsApp hits 160 million active users in India, its biggest market
- 'Crazy Ex
-
ListentoarticlePresident Asif Ali Zardari has conferred the prestigious Hilal-e-Imtiaz on Olympic go ...[详细]
-
The push to make the thinnest, lightest, most portable laptop is proving fruitful. Case in point: th ...[详细]
-
Donald Trump refuses to be a gracious winner
Tuesday marked one week since Donald Trump shocked everyone, including himself, by winning the presi ...[详细] -
Bill Cosby convicted of sexual assault
After 14 hours of deliberation, the jury found Bill Cosby guilty of sexual assault, according to CNN ...[详细] -
Our galaxy might crash into Andromeda. What would happen to Earth?
Our Milky Way galaxy is a cannibal.It has grown by consuming other galaxies. Yet, it too, may be des ...[详细] -
China: Envoy voices opposition to U.S. shield in Seoul
China's chief nuclear envoy, Wu Dawei, has voiced the country's opposition to the possible deploymen ...[详细] -
South Korea pushes for groundbreaking ceremony for inter
A train bound from South Korea heads to Jejin Station in Goseong County in Gangwon Province in May 2 ...[详细] -
汉源县新县城2号复合安置项目建设现场 日前召开的汉源县新县城2号复合安置工程奋战70天施工生产动员大会上,提出了“奋战70天,保质保量保进度,争取早日完成工程任务”的奋斗目标,“多建一平方米住房,少一 ...[详细]
-
Tesla's big software update includes something called 'Night Curfew'
Tesla's latest car update is great news for parents who (unwisely?) let their kids borrow the car, a ...[详细] -
“回雅安举办一场小提琴独奏公益音乐会,回馈家乡的父老乡亲。”旅居海外的小提琴家李钟灵心里一直有这样的梦想。 7月24日19时45分,雅安剧场,众人聆听,一场音乐盛宴在这里上演。 33岁的雅女李钟灵 ...[详细]