The Pigskin Experiment: 3
In case you didn’t hear, the first-ever 3-D broadcast of an NFL game recently went down. Don’t worry if you missed it, because your old buddy The Grouse was present to bring you this report from the front lines. Or, the line of scrimmage, as it were.
The NFL hopes to someday bring 3-D football to the pigskin loving public at large. This preview was a demo of what we might someday see play out in movie theaters across the country. That’s right—the game was shown in the same type of movie theaters you’d watch one of those Disney 3-D movies in, which should be your first clue that this was definitely a different way of watching football.
As I entered the theater, I was handed a pair of 3-D specs, which looked more like a pair of Risky BusinessRay Bans than the classic cardboard blue-and-reds. After a couple of laps around the room in search of a decent seat, I finally settled in just before kickoff.
I’m going to skip the drum roll and just tell you that what I saw up on that big screen was definitely … OK. Let’s start with the good:
Pardon the cheeseball PR word, but the broadcast was undeniably ‘immersive.’ The 3-D cameras gave the field a sense of depth that I’ve never experienced at a sporting event before, either on TV or in person. It was kind of like watching the game through a ViewMaster—you had things like the refs, security guards and first-down markers in front of you in the foreground, while the on-field action happened on a different plane just behind everything else. On-screen graphics and instant replays were particularly nice on the eyes, and no fewer than twenty times did I turn to the friend next to me to say, “That was cool!” or “Did you see that?” I also really enjoyed sitting in a movie theater, drinking a beer and talking to the people around me at normal conversational volume—this was definitely a new experience.
At the same time, however, there were some fairly fundamental problems with the 3-D broadcast, which make me question whether it’ll ever be suitable for public consumption.
The depth of field I describe was certainly cool, but that’s really all there was to it. You didn’t have linebackers blitzing towards the camera, and the ball never looked like it was going to torpedo right out of the screen. Every single camera angle was a set up for the same visual trick: Dazzle the viewer with a few things in the foreground. Unfortunately, more often than not that was done with a shameless shot of a cheerleader shaking her pom poms in your face. Otherwise, it was a shot of the same few painted-up super fans who had been told to point tauntingly at the camera. Both wore on me pretty quickly.
I also found the scarcity of on-screen graphics slightly off-putting. Yeah, they looked cool and futuristic when they popped off of the screen at you, but then they’d go away. There was nothing attached to the screen to tell you the score, the down or how much time was left in a quarter. I’m sure that’s a technical issue having to do with too many things happening on-screen at once, but it’s definitely something that needs to be fixed.
My biggest beef with the 3-D game, though, is that it was actually hard to follow the ball. Instant replays looked amazing because the action was slowed down. But, at regular speed everything went blurry and was difficult to make out. Whenever the ball was passed or kicked, it was anybody’s guess as to where it would end up.
In other words, this broadcast wasn’t really about the football at all. It was about the gimmick of 3-D. In fact, the only time I ever heard “oohs” and “aahs” out of the crowd was during TV timeouts. That’s when the 3-D audience was subjected to some random eye candy of a snowboarder spraying snow at the camera and a surfer barreling right towards us. Nice, but I came to see football and there was none of that same gee-whiz kind of excitement during game play. Wanna wow me? Strap a 3-D unit to the overhead cablecam and swoop in and out of the action like an IMAX nature doc nose-diving into the Grand Canyon.
Technical issues aside, I think the bigger problem has to do with the way people watch football. When the NFL eventually rolls this thing out across America, will we be allowed to tailgate in the cineplex parking lot? Will Buffalo wings and pulled-pork sandwiches be available at the concession stand? More importantly, will beer be served? The game I attended was a press event with a full bar, but when I asked if alcohol would be served at public events, the answer was, “We don’t know.” I don’t expect most movie theaters to go through the rigmarole of obtaining a liquor license, and what theater operator in his right mind would allow alcohol, anyway?
See, when we leave the home to watch football, it becomes less about the game and more about socializing. We want to eat, drink and be loud. We want to yell at the screen and yell at each other. Some of us want to paint parts of our bodies. But, while watching this game in 3-D, it was hard to escape the feeling of being “at the movies.” The room was dark and everyone was sitting eyes-forward like in a lecture hall. Yes, talking was certainly allowed, but doing your team’s chant or orchestrating a wave would have seemed out of place.
For NFL in 3-D work, it needs to deliver a killer football viewing experience or it needs to deliver the social aspect. Unfortunately, in its current form it does neither—or it does both kind of halfway.
That said, I still really enjoyed myself, if only for the novelty of it all And, this was only the first try, remember. Who knows how the experience might be improved and the technology better implemented? If your neighborhood theater starts showing NFL games in 3-D next season, I recommend you go and check one out. You probably won’t make a regular habit of it, but you’re sure to see something you’ve never seen before. Sadly, mall parking lot keg stands aren’t likely to be one of them.
(责任编辑:产品中心)
- CeeDee Lamb secures record
- 农村群众 新年景新希望
- North Korean leader sends another congratulatory message to Cuba's new president
- 昨起迎返程高峰 高速路段道路基本顺畅
- 优化广东优质农产品产销资源对接!“农友圈”又有新动作
- 17 Spectacular Outdoor Staircases
- Yelp is having a truly brutal day
- Tension mounts between prosecution and Justice Ministry
- 探索郁南无核黄皮百亿产业发展方案,培优扶强行动走进郁南黄皮产区
- Eng name ODI, T20I squads for Aus series
- Facebook empowers Page owners to politicize their posts
- 农村群众 新年景新希望
- Should the Premier League season be cancelled?
-
Yes, big spiders are spreading in the U.S. No, they're not flying.
They're not after you. And they don't "parachute" from the sky.Periodically, people and headlines on ...[详细] -
●不少农户在灾后恢复重建中因建房用完了积蓄,他看在眼里,急在心上,放弃公司营销岗位返乡●他投资60万元启动“高端药材发展计划”,成立起中药材种植农民专业合作社,5户灾后重建户成为社员●返乡至今,他为本 ...[详细]
-
雅安日报讯17日,中央电视台财经频道《经济半小时》栏目播出《灾区迎新年:深山里的新家园》节目,栏目组在我市芦山县、宝兴县和雨城区取点拍摄,通过实地采访受灾群众、学生、基层村干部等群体,回顾“4·20” ...[详细]
-
South Korea's intelligence chief leaves for US to coordinate policy on North Korea
National Intelligence Service Director Park Jie-won walks toward his departure gate at Incheon Inter ...[详细] -
雅州利剑集中攻坚执行大会战专项行动启动走进位于青衣江畔雨城区三雅路6号的雅安市中级人民法院,办公环境窗明几净,法院干警热情服务……一缕缕文明新风扑面而来。文明的厚度,决定发展的高度。2018年,获“四 ...[详细]
-
Michelle Obama takes memorable final stroll through the 'People's House'
Michelle Obama has two days left in the White House, and she's using them to make us cry.On Wednesda ...[详细] -
春节“黄金周”接待游客123.34万人次,同比增长25.54%;旅游收入8.15亿元,同比增长33.02%大年初一,前往市区金凤寺景区的游客摩肩接踵连日来,全市大部分地区天气晴朗,激发了市民和游客游览 ...[详细]
-
Marco Rubio suspends his campaign.
Update, 8:38 p.m.: Marco Rubio suspended his campaign in an speech shortly after Florida was called. ...[详细] -
Transitioning to 100% renewable energy globally would be cheaper and simpler using firebricks, a for ...[详细]
-
创意海报丨第九届四川农博会广东展品抢先看,“广东嘢样样好!”
创意海报丨第九届四川农博会广东展品抢先看,“广东嘢样样好!”_南方+_南方plus在第九届四川农业博览会举办前夕,广东展团正紧锣密鼓的做着最后的布展工作。跨越千里,奔赴山海之约。广东这次到底带来了哪些 ...[详细]
- Yes, big spiders are spreading in the U.S. No, they're not flying.
- Is the GOP going to get away with blocking Merrick Garland?
- Moon wishes for 'fair country' in Chuseok message
- Football's return 'good for everyone': Mourinho
- Pragmocracy Now
- PSG awarded Ligue 1 title as French football season declared over
- North Korea will not participate in World Cup qualifiers in South Korea next month