Proposed special tribunal on judiciary power abuse stokes legal controversy
Lawmakers’ push to launch a special tribunal on the judiciary power abuse scandal involving a former top court chief is stoking controversy among legal experts over fairness and judicial independence.
Floor leaders of the ruling Democratic Party and three minor opposition parties said in a joint press conference last Friday that a special tribunal must be launched to “fairly handle” the allegations that former Supreme Court Chief Justice Yang Sung-tae led the abuse of judicial power.
Papers leaked from the National Court Administration early this year raised suspicions that NCA officials under Yang attempted to use politically sensitive trials to seek support from then President Park Geun-hye’s office for Yang’s bid to establish a court of appeal.
In August, lawmakers, including Rep. Park Ju-min of the Democratic Party, proposed a special bill to have three special judges preside over the first and second trials of the judicial power abuse allegations.
According to the bill, the Korean Bar Association, a council of judges and “knowledgeable and highly reputed” non-legal practitioners, or civic groups, would each pick three people to form a nine-person panel that will recommend twice the number of required special tribunal judges from the Seoul Central District Court. The Supreme Court chief justice would then appoint the special judges from the list of recommended judges.
The DP and the three minor opposition parties seek to get the bill passed next month, but some legal experts argue that it may be unconstitutional as nothing is stated in the Constitution in regard to the establishment of a special tribunal.
There is no clause about a special tribunal in the law on court organization either.
Those opposed to the special tribunal argue that it would violate Chapter 5, Article 101 of the Constitution which states that “judicial power shall be vested in courts composed of judges,” since the tribunal will be organized by politicians.
Having non-legal practitioners and members of the Korean Bar Association on the panel that recommends the judges is against the constitutional guarantee of judicial power, they argue.
Rep. Park and those who favor the special tribunal argue otherwise, noting that it is the Supreme Court chief justice who will ultimately form the special tribunal, and that the tribunal’s judges will picked from among incumbent judges.
Another point of contention is that, from the prospective defendants’ point of view, the special tribunal may infringe on their right to fair trial.
Many argue that the tribunal will be formed based on a predetermined notion that those implicated in the power abuse scandal are guilty.
The tribunal is likely to be swayed by public opinion in reaching its conclusion, instead of ruling based on evidence and their conscience as judges, they say.
“If it’s going to be formed according to the current bill, it would be like ruling on a case that has already been concluded,” a judge said.
Compared to regular courts where judges are randomly assigned cases, the special tribunal may lack fairness since it will comprise judges recommended by civic groups that do not trust the judiciary and the Korean Bar Association, which may see themselves as a victim of the alleged judicial power abuse, some opponents of the tribunal claim.
Those pushing for the tribunal say that this is not true, as the defendants can be tried three times like in other cases, and the same trial procedures will apply to them as well.
There is also an argument over whether it would infringe on judicial independence.
Senior Presidential Secretary for Civil affairs Cho Kuk wrote in a Facebook post on Saturday that the push for a special tribunal is “based on reasonable doubt that it will be difficult for the judges to rule fairly” on the alleged judicial power abuse case, prompting criticism that Cho, a legal scholar, was out of his line as a key presidential aide.
In a recent poll of 502 adults nationwide by Realmeter showed 3 out of 5 respondents favoring the establishment of a special tribunal for a fair trial on allegations against Yang.
By Kim So-hyun (sophie@heraldcorp.com)
(责任编辑:行业动态)
- How to watch 'Kinds of Kindness': When is it streaming?
- Scottish man takes cousin's birthday request for 'Frozen' pyjamas very literally
- 'One of the best I've seen': Guardiola salutes sublime Silva
- N. Korea closes embassy in Spain following shutdown of missions in Africa
- Unionized hospital workers pull out from strike
- 中山古镇:到苏炳添家乡看“村BA”,来一场说走就走的美食之旅
- N. Korea calls US 'war merchant' over support for Israel in war with Hamas
- Lions surround you in this 360
- Mattis: US troops in Korea not issue to discuss with N. Korea
- Spate of defections show Kim Jong
- 地震当日 他带着武警官兵挺进灾区
- Korea's older senior employment rate tops OECD countries
- Solskjaer condemns racist abuse of Rashford as Palace stun Man Utd
-
10 Big Misconceptions About Computer Hardware
With technology advancing so rapidly around us, sometimes misconceptions can work their way into our ...[详细] -
US envoy calls for 'durable solutions' to improve NK human rights
Julie Turner, U.S. special envoy for North Korean human rights, attends a media roundtable at the Am ...[详细] -
Avocado Rat is the millennial version of Pizza Rat
It's been two years since a rat struggled to drag a hefty slice of pizza along a few subway stairs i ...[详细] -
Rare frilled shark with unusual teeth and 'snake
Sink your teeth into this.A little-known frilled shark has been found off the Algarve coast in Portu ...[详细] -
Update your BIOS: Utilities from Top Motherboard Makers
PSA:Enthusiasts building their own PCs are accustomed to keeping up with latest drivers, especially ...[详细] -
N. Korea to close its embassy in Uganda: report
Uganda's President Yoweri Kaguta Museveni, center, and North Korea's Ambassador to Kampala, Jong Ton ...[详细] -
Couple's photo series finds humor in their struggle with infertility
Infertility can create years of difficult, emotional turmoil. For Whitney and Spencer Blake, they de ...[详细] -
Here's why it's a bad idea to put your phone's screen up on live TV
Sometimes the thought of sabotaging your friend's live TV appearance proves too difficult to resist. ...[详细] -
Doosan scraps controversial Robotics
(Doosan Group)Doosan Group has officially scrapped its merger plan between Doosan Robotics and Doosa ...[详细] -
1 in 10 Korean babies use smartphones before 12 months: study
Nearly 4 out of 10 young children aged between 2 and 5 in South Korea watch television, while more t ...[详细]
- 热浪来袭 科学应对防中暑
- Why Rian Johnson's Star Wars trilogy should be the ultimate origin story
- Chrissy Teigen remains wonderful, spray tans remain problematic
- Why heterosexuals are so obsessed with height in online dating
- Korea's economy to stop growing without drastic labor change: FKI
- US envoy calls for 'durable solutions' to improve NK human rights
- N. Korea slams US test launch of Minuteman III ICBM