Shani Louk Picture of the Year controversy: Why the winning photograph isn’t really war photography.
Two weeks ago, a group of photographers from the Associated Press took first prize in the Pictures of the Year competition, run by the Donald W. Reynolds Journalism Institute at the Missouri School of Journalism, in the Team Picture Story of the Year category for 20 photos of the Israel-Hamas war. The featured photo is of Shani Louk, a 22-year-old German-Israeli civilian. She is lying facedown in a truck bed, partly naked and most likely dead, being driven through the streets of Gaza in the hours after the Oct. 7 massacre at the Nova festival. The men in the back of the truck brandish machine guns and grenade launchers. One of them casually drapes his leg over Louk’s exposed torso while another looks straight at the camera and points emphatically at her.
What are we to make of the choice to recognize this photo with an award? On the one hand, the image reflects the way much of the left has viewed Israeli victims following Oct. 7—disposed of, expendable, taken away, gone. On the other hand, it captures the paradox that has allowed Hamas supporters to simultaneously deny that atrocities against women took place on Oct. 7 while celebrating them in real time. Ultimately, the choice to center and honor this image also perfectly captures the intersection of antisemitism and misogyny, as well as the way elements of the left and Hamas are joined in their shared antipathy toward Jews.
AdvertisementSome have suggestedthat the picture of Louk is deserving of recognition as part of a long tradition of war photojournalism, a practice that stretches back to Mathew Brady’s images of the dead at Antietam. That was the position of Picture of the Year director Lynden Steele, who claimed that the image captures “the harsh realities of war” and therefore merited the award. We understand the merits of war photojournalism, just as we understand that awarding a photograph a prize is not equivalent to celebrating its contents. But the picture of Louk is not war photojournalism. It was taken not during wartime but during a terror attack. The men in the back of the truck are not “fighting.” They are not even wearing uniforms or insignia. They are returning from a pogrom with their spoils, to publicly desecrate a captured corpse. Louk’s family was able to identify her only because viral real-time video of her body paraded through the streets allowed them to recognize tattoos and dreadlocks. Bone fragments from her skull were later found at the Nova festival, suggesting she had been killed at the site.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementThe casual verbal slippage between war photojournalism and crime scene photography is manifest in another simple trick: In announcing the AP’s win, the award organizers reposted the unblurred image of Louk on their Instagram page but neglected to include her name. Her name did, however, appear in the prize announcement on the award website, in which the chosen caption says it all:
Heavy Israeli airstrikes on the enclave has killed thousands of Palestinians. Palestinian militants drive back to the Gaza Strip with the body of Shani Louk, a German-Israeli dual citizen, during their cross-border attack on Israel, Saturday, Oct. 7, 2023.
That caption reorders the sequence of events, as if the subsequent bombing of Gaza were the cause of the cross-border attack. In this telling, these militants found themselves with a half-naked female “body” in the bed of their truck in some accident of war. It distorts the fact that Louk was murdered during a cease-fire and her corpse taken as bounty. Deliberately conflating Hamas’ sexual violence, kidnappings, and burning of women and children with acts of combat gives away the game from the start. However you opt to perceive it, an atmosphere that celebrates this image sets back decades of international legal advances recognizing the dignity and rights of women.
Advertisement AdvertisementPerhaps the photo merits an award by sensitively capturing the plight of the victims of Oct. 7? That was the line the AP’s vice president of corporate communications, Lauren Easton, gave following international outrage about the prize. “Documenting breaking news events around the world—no matter how horrific—is our job,” she said. “Without AP and other news organizations, the world would not have known what was happening on Oct. 7.” But that is also untrue. In this case, the perpetrators filmed their own acts in viral videos captured on GoPros and livestreamed them to the world, screaming “Allahu Akbar!” (“God is great!”) and driving through the streets. In other instances such footage was shared with the victims’ families using the victims’ own phones. One could well ask whether we should consider a journalistic image of one of the most photographed violent pogroms in modern history to constitute essential newsgathering or whether we should instead regard it as prurient rubbernecking. Yet the Donald W. Reynolds Journalism Institute saw fit to reward the impulse with a prize.
Advertisement AdvertisementImages of war can be aimed at producing empathy for the victim or anger and disgust toward the perpetrators (or both). Indeed, most of the photos that garnered this prestigious prize do just that. This photograph does neither. The victim, Louk, is an object, almost illegible as a person, reduced by her captors to a trophy. The perpetrators delightin that fact. Most remarkable about the picture is the extent to which it manages to simultaneously deny the crime and celebrate it. On its face, the photo and the caption accompanying it evince no interest at all in how she came to be a “body,” instead observing the time-honored adage invoked whenever a female victim is involved: “She deserved it.”
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementRelated From Slate
Emily Tamkin
Why the World Central Kitchen Aid Workers’ Deaths Broke Through the Horror of This War
Read MoreThis elision—from recognizing war photography in Gaza to celebrating gender-based violence during a cease-fire—isn’t subtle. The photo depicting Louk and those who chose to use her undressed body as a symbol reflect and reproduce the response to the plight of Israeli women in progressive circles. When word started to get out about the gender-based sexual violence committed on Oct. 7, international institutions, feminist organizations, academia, and progressive media offered three different though often overlapping responses. The first was justification of the acts perpetrated by Hamas as resistance and liberation. Feminist philosopher Judith Butler, for example, recently objected to referring to the events of Oct. 7 as a terrorist attack, describing them as an “uprising” and “an act of armed resistance.” Outside Columbia University, a sign has been hung for months now—it reads: “Resistance by Any Means Necessary.” The second response has been denial, either of the acts themselves or to their systemic and premeditated nature. This manifested in a deafening silence for months after the attacks, then with media outlets “just raising questions” about whether the attacks had been spontaneous rather than systematic, cloaked in claims about Hamas’ respect for and reverence of women’s bodies. The third response recognized the violence inherent in the acts but criticized those highlighting the crimes because it perhaps risked weaponizing rape to justify Israel’s campaign in Gaza. But justify it, deny it, or bothsides it—rape is still rape. Diminishing it for transactional political reasons is still gaslighting.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementIt is undeniably essential to photograph war and famine and the suffering in Gaza as a means of keeping a public record. But the Picture of the Year prize opted to recirculate an image that was not captured or contextualized in print as an indictment. Louk’s family has explicitly asked, many times, that she be remembered alive and happy. When told that the photo of his dead daughter had won an award, Louk’s father, Nissim, said he hoped that the attention the award would garner for the photo would serve “to inform the future,” but whether that reckoning will happen remains unclear. Louk’s grandmother Nicole Louk Naccache decried not just the award but the public silence, posting Thursday: “My dead granddaughter stars in a photograph that won a prestigious photography competition. And the world is silent! … Tossed as a victory trophy for terrorists and vile photographers.”
AdvertisementPopular in News & Politics
- The Lawyer Defending Idaho’s Abortion Ban Irritated the One Justice He Needed on His Side
- You Don’t Want to Know How It’s Going Between Trump’s Lawyers and the Judge Presiding Over His Criminal Case
- We’ve Been Entertaining an Illusion About the Supreme Court. It’s Finally Been Shattered.
- Prosecutors Are Finally Revealing Their Strategy Against Trump
Meanwhile, the AP has been named in a suit filed by survivors and family members of the massacre for knowingly supporting terrorism by purchasing photos from Hamas-linked journalists. The AP has also been sued separately by Louk’s family for employing freelance photojournalists who broke through the Gaza fence with the terrorists, then documented the killings. When asked why it would work with a photographer who presumably had material knowledge of crimes committed that day, the AP has chosen to insist that it “had no knowledge of the Oct. 7 attacks before they happened.” The organization has yet to explain why it is acceptable to have knowledge of the attacks and the attackers as they happened.
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights states in Article 1 that “all human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights.” The award-winning photo of Louk, snapped by a freelancer along for the ride, suggests that human dignity can be stolen twice, once with impunity and again for journalistic accolades.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:关于我们)
- Smiley face on Mars is a telltale sign of its past
- 真情相助 就业扶贫
- N. Korea reveals mosaic mural of Kim Jong
- 冠军最高2748公斤/亩 !2023年荔枝龙眼园高产竞赛结果揭晓
- A Global Tour of Bakeries With Fascinating Histories
- Ford can make your Mustang Mach
- Signal could make NBA's tampering problem even harder to solve
- Trump's suspicion of North Korean leader exposed by former US diplomat in interview
- US ambassador opposes redeploying tactical nukes in South Korea
- PS5 Pro: There are new whispers that the release date is fast approaching
- 夫妻遗失1万多元治疗费 民警追踪4小时将其找回
- Cabinet approves immigration law revision to grant long
- Pornhub launches first
-
How to trademark your TikTok phrase and protect your brand
So, you had a video go viral and it had a very specific phrase, like "Hawk Tuah on that thang" or "v ...[详细] -
Cabinet approves immigration law revision to grant long
Afghan evacuees play football at the National Human Resources Development Institute in Jinchon, 91 k ...[详细] -
2023驻镇这一年 | 驻镇帮镇扶村短视频大“晒”一周精选98)_南方+_南方plus以“乡村‘镇’能量,越‘晒’粤精彩”为主题的广东省乡村振兴驻镇帮镇扶村短视频大“晒”活动于2022年2月全面启动。 ...[详细]
-
89 cities, counties, wards designated as depopulation areas
Minister of the Interior and Safety Jeon Hae-cheol announces the designation of 89 cities, counties ...[详细] -
South Korean table tennis player Shin Yu-bin eats a banana before her women's singles semifinal ...[详细]
-
NK says S. Korea, US will pay 'terrible price' if they use force
An F-35B stealth fighter from U.S. Marine Fighter Attack Squadron 242 takes off from an air base in ...[详细] -
Nadal feared he would never play again after foot injury
MELBOURNE:Rafael Nadal said on Friday that his foot injury last year was so bad he thought he might ...[详细] -
NSC strongly condemns N. Korea's barrage of overnight provocations
National Security Adviser Kim Sung-han, second from left, presides over a National Security Council ...[详细] -
You're playing the latest Call of Mario: Deathduty Battleyardon your perfect gaming PC. You're looki ...[详细]
-
这波团圆饭的松弛感,高要拿捏住了!_南方+_南方plus今年的大年三十不放假相信广大打工人心中留下了诸多疑问“还赶得上除夕夜团聚吗?”“这年夜饭还能不能吃上?”“年菜第一区”高要喊各位先别急高要年味一 ...[详细]
- Newborns hit new low, but births to those unmarried reach record high: data
- First frost of season spotted in Seoul as chilly weather continues
- 预见2024丨中国预制菜行业六大趋势预测
- iFixit teardown confirms the iPhone 12 and 12 Pro are mostly identical
- To Russia, with Love
- 'The Office' stars recall an iconic cold open and some best lines of the series
- Yes, you can teach your cat to fetch