Stop buying into the idea of a skincare 'holy grail'
Before deepfakes and alternative facts, the online world was already telling us fibs. In our series Lies the Internet Told Me, we call 'em all out.
The term "holy grail" has become standard in beauty reviews and in online communities dedicated to skincare. The phrase generally refers to a skincare product so effective that it can singlehandedly transform someone's skin for the better. Sure, other products may lend an assist, but the holy grail — like its Biblical counterpart — is the one with the miraculous powers.
Dozens of beauty articles are dedicated to holy grails: reviews, "top-shelf" profiles, product roundups sourced from Reddit or gleaned from other beauty writers. The same brands and products — Drunk Elephant's Vitamin C serum, Sunday Riley's Good Genes, Glossier's Solution, and CeraVe's Hydrating Face Wash — are praised frequently.
"Okay so I know this is an investment but TRUST ME it's the best investment you can make in your face," reads one review of Good Genes. (The post is sponsored by Sephora.) "I would die for this."
"Ask a person with sensitive skin what their holy-grail product is and there's a 99% chance they'll say Cetaphil," notes another blurb.
While these testimonials don't explicitly declare the products universally good, it's implied that they're reliable investments for people looking to improve their skin. (So reliable, in fact, that they're worth the often — though not always — staggering cost. At Sephora, Good Genes costs $105 per ounce.)
Tweet may have been deleted
It's true that some skincare products work for more people than others. It's true that some skincare products contain fewer common irritants than others. But there is no single product able to transform every type of skin on Earth. There is no actual holy grail.
SEE ALSO:Does Kylie Jenner even know how to wash her face?Dr. Tara Rao, a dermatologist at Schweiger Dermatology Group in NYC, said in an interview that she doesn't often hear the term around her office. When she sees it online, however, she takes it with a grain of salt. Holy grails are "products that someone finds highly effective that are not going to be appropriate or effective for everyone," she said.
If you're a skincare enthusiast, you're probably thinking, Duh. Of course not every skincare product works for everyone. But for people getting into skincare for the first time, the constant framing of certain products as magical cure-alls can lead to some seriously fruitless investments.
The constant framing of products as magical cure-alls can lead to fruitless investments.
When I decided to start a skincare routine in earnest, I was particularly susceptible to holy-grail messaging. I had just moved to NYC, and with the city air came new irritations my sensitive skin didn't know how to handle. Unfortunately, I also had no money, so I opted for one of the least expensive, most beloved cleansers out there: Cetaphil.
For the first few days, I didn't notice any improvements, but my skin seemed fine. Then, suddenly, my face erupted in painful acne that simply wouldn't go away. I exfoliated, I spot-treated, I did nothing except cleanse and moisturize. It didn't matter. Every remedy proved useless.
The only thing I didn't do was stop using the Cetaphil, which I figured was so innocuous it couldn't possibly be causing the problem. But when I accidentally left it at home during a trip and used a different cleanser for a week, my skin cleared up. That's when I realized: This holy grail did not work for me at all.
Even if a holy grail doesn't outright damage the skin, it can make the consumer feel like they've made a useless purchase. Martha, a creative professional in Brooklyn, had that experience with Drunk Elephant's C-Firma, a much-lauded vitamin C serum that costs $80 per ounce. She didn't hate the serum, and it didn't hurt her skin. Ultimately, though, she felt like it wasn't doing anything.
"I never noticed major changes and felt like it wasn’t worth it to keep buying it in case it might change my skin for the better," she explained via Twitter DM. "I’m impatient — and have found products that make me look glow-y right away as opposed to [far] down the line."
View this post on Instagram
Holy-grail culture has much to do with brands' focus on providing what appears to be quick, straightforward gratification. This idea permeates shopping culture, from Amazon Prime to Seamless to the pre-made cheese plates at Starbucks. Beauty brands are no exception. Take Glossier, for instance. Its exfoliator, Solution, is referred to on the company's website as an "exfoliating skin perfecter." Its mission? To "transform." Damn! Sounds like a holy grail, no? (Like everything else, it is not: Three people told me over Twitter DM that they noticed virtually no change in their skin after making Solution part of their routine.)
Brands, being brands, will try to get you to buy their stuff. This is just marketing, which is not a new idea. But as far as skincare is concerned, buying into the idea of a magical "perfecter" is a recipe for disaster.
A skincare routine, after all, is mostly developed through boring old trial-and-error, probably with several false starts. According to Dr. Rao, you should give a new product around four to six weeks before you know if it's actually working — unless, of course, you have a reaction (looking at you, Cetaphil), in which case it's OK to abandon ship. It's also important to introduce only one new product at a time. If you're incorporating your entire Sephora haul at once, you won't be able to tell which products are helping and which are hurting.
Most importantly, don't feel like you have to try a skincare product because a lot of people (or affiliate-linked product roundups) endorse it. There are thousands of choices out there, and the ones that work for you could be anything: cheap, expensive, prescription, from the wellness aisle at Whole Foods. But you're not going to know what they are from reading MakeupAlley. You actually have to put them on your face.
Featured Video For You
How much water do you really need?
(责任编辑：行业动态)
'Black Myth: Wukong' PS5 review in progress: A potential masterpiece
冬天来了 盘点我市五花八门的保暖产品
推进煤矿企业安全生产诚信建设
足不出户 也能解决问题-
八仙帽精美的刺绣作品周学琼左）、唐伟欣右）在门口刺绣藏彝走廊东部边缘的石棉县，在横断山脉的褶皱、隆起与断裂，以及河流的急剧切割作用下，群山峡谷中藏着一个藏族秘境——蟹螺堡子。石头和泥土砌成的房屋展示着
...[详细]
-
本报讯 “持续3天的全市公安机关社会治安冬季行动节前集中统一清查整治行动正式开始，各县区公安机关按既定方案开展行动！”2月9日晚8点半，全市公安机关举行社会治安冬季行动节前集中统一清查整治行动视频调
...[详细]
-
雅安日报讯 疏散顾客、关上房门、切断电源……24日晚，消防部门组织消防官兵在市区娱乐会所举行了公共娱乐场所消防实战演练，并召集市区各娱乐场所的负责人前来观摩。 当日19时许，市区挺进路一娱乐会所二
...[详细]
-
蔚蓝天空中，飘着朵朵白云。瀑布沟电站下闸蓄水后，形成了宽阔的湖面。时值初春，已有汉源群众驾船行驶在人工湖上，沉浸在湖光山色中。 据了解，瀑布沟电站建成后，将形成84平方公里的湖面和长约84千米的库区
...[详细]
-
Expanded police surveillance will get us “broken windows” on steroids.
Across the United States, cities are spending a larger share of the money at their disposal buying a
...[详细]
-
“家电下乡”这一惠民政策，让广大农村消费者在用上新家电产品的同时，也享受到了国家的惠民政策。今年1月，财政部、商务部、工信部等联合发布通知，将12类下乡产品限价范围大幅提高，如彩电和手机的最高限价提
...[详细]
-
放阳灯祈福新年烟花迎春春到雁归来选购年货除夕夜姹紫嫣红祈福·春节春节游金凤山本组图片由记者 高晓军 摄
...[详细]
-
一月，一个适合旅行的日子，你准备好了吗？ 九寨沟冰瀑 推荐：四川九寨沟 冰瀑旅游节——看冰瀑，观奇景，南国冰雪世界。 理由：每年一月九寨沟冰瀑节开幕，冰封的九寨展现另一个迷人的景致。山峦与树木银装素
...[详细]
-
11 Telescopes Exploring The Magic of Space
Perhaps no invention has broadened our understanding of the universe more than the telescope. The ve
...[详细]
-
广东10个村入选！2023年中国美丽休闲乡村名单公布_南方+_南方plus记者从农业农村部官网获悉，2023年中国美丽休闲乡村名单已于9月14日正式公布，北京市房山区张坊镇大峪沟村等256个村落为20
...[详细]
