Trump nominee Brett Talley’s apparent thoughts on capital punishment: “Just shoot them.”
Since his confirmation hearings for a seat on the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Alabama, 36-year-old Brett Talley has come under criticism for his relative inexperience, his failure to disclose that his wife works as a lawyer in Trump’s White House, and the fact that he didn’t reveal that he’d apparently written a series of pseudonymous message board posts on the website TideFans.com under the username BamainBoston.
In those posts, which covered a wide range of sports and nonsports topics, BamainBoston was open about his enthusiasm for the death penalty. In 2015, for example, BamainBoston noted that it would be “awesome” if Alabama brought back the electric chair. Later in the thread, BamainBoston proposed an alternative means of execution, saying that a “bullet’s cheap.” One year earlier, responding to news that an Oklahoma inmate named Clayton Lockett had died of a heart attack on the gurney after his lethal injection was botched, BamainBoston wrote: “Just shoot them. That’s effective.”
In a post this year, BamainBoston indicated he had worked on capital punishment cases in his career. That post read as follows:
Handled a bunch of death row cases in my previous job. With one exception, every one of them admitted that they’d committed the crime but were trying to mitigate to life without parole based on some excuse—drugs, violent childhood, etc. And the one exception the guy was clearly guilty. I don’t know the details on this Arkansas case, but death row cases with an actual innocence claim are kind of like abortions based on rape, incest, or the life of the mother. They certainly happen, but the whole debate shouldn’t turn on them.Advertisement
BamainBoston’s message came in a thread titled “Arkansas May Have Just Executed an Innocent Man.” That man, Ledell Lee, was executed earlier this year. Elizabeth Vartkessian of the Marshall Project wrote that the “courts refused to allow Lee’s team to conduct DNA testing and new evidence of his likely intellectual disability was never heard.” BamainBoston opined, “I wouldn’t spend too much time weeping for Lee.”
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementAs a district court judge, Talley could hear capital criminal cases. At least 18 former death row inmates have been exonerated by DNA evidence and released from prison, the Innocence Project reported in 2009. BamainBoston expressed skepticism that anyone had been executed wrongfully since the Supreme Court reinstated the death penalty in 1977, writing:
AdvertisementAnti-death penalty advocates have gone to great lengths to definitively identify someone from the modern era who was executed and was innocent, Roger Keith Coleman being probably the most famous failed example. But that is beside my point. Feel free to change the standard for the death penalty if you like and give people who make claims of actual innocence yet another appeal process, or have a higher standard for imposition of the death penalty itself, beyond not only a reasonable doubt but any doubt. Do whatever you want, because the vast majority of people on death row are unequivocally and admittedly guilty.
In response to follow-up questions from Sen. Dick Durbin, a member of the Senate Judiciary Committee, Talley listed his work on death penalty cases as one of his key qualifications as a potential federal judge. In his own follow-up questions, Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse noted that Talley had in his role as deputy solicitor general of Alabama “defended questionable practices concerning the death penalty, such as executing a mentally incompetent death-row inmate and allowing a judge to override a jury’s recommendation for a life sentence and impose the death penalty.” Talley’s response:
Advertisement AdvertisementI defended the practices to which you refer in my capacity as an attorney representing a client, the state of Alabama. Those representations will have no influence on my sentencing practices, other than providing familiarity and experience with the legal issues surrounding the death penalty and challenges to sentences generally.Advertisement
The Supreme Court ultimately sided with Talley’s view in the case of the mentally incompetent death row inmate. Earlier this month, the court unanimously struck down a lower court ruling blocking the execution of a man who couldn’t remember his crime—but could understand the concepts of crime and punishment—after having suffered a series of strokes.
Find anything noteworthy in BamainBoston’s message board posts? Email us at tips@slate.com.
See also:
Trump Judicial Nominee Brett Talley Appears to Have Defended “the First KKK” in Message Board Post
Trump Judicial Nominee Brett Talley Appears to Have Called Roe v. Wade “Indefensible”
Trump Nominee Brett Talley Appears to Support 20-Year-Old Woman Having Sex with 14-Year-Old Boy
(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- Pakistan to host South Africa before ICC Women’s T20 World Cup
- The U.S. officially rejoins the Paris Agreement on climate change.
- From North Korean defector to UK election candidate: Park fights for 'voiceless'
- Everything Apple announced at the iPhone 14 event
- N. Korea test
- NYT Strands hints, answers for August 29
- 'Love Is Love' slogan tries to sanitise queerness for straight people
- Everything Apple announced at the iPhone 14 event
- NASA simulation shows what it's like to fly into black hole's point of no return
- Listeners encouraged to go wild with Le Sserafim's 4th EP
- Spurs' shambolic season puts Levy in the firing line
- GoPro reveals the HERO11 Black and its adorable Mini
- How to choose a sex toy
-
The world's largest single-capacity floating wind platform has set to sea and the builder released i ...[详细]
-
Your climate change denial TikToks are getting deleted
Happy Earth Day! TikTok is making moves to ban all climate change denial content on its platform.Sta ...[详细] -
Military parade pressures Biden to take North Korea seriously
North Korea displays new submarine-launched ballistic missiles during a military parade in Pyongyang ...[详细] -
这周末“真香”!“疆味”盛宴进湾区,活动亮点抢先看_南方+_南方plus提起新疆,你会想到什么?别具一格的自然风光,数不胜数的特色美食,多彩多姿的民族风情,悠久浓厚的文化底蕴……12月16-18日,“ ...[详细]
-
iPhone 16 Pro new color will reportedly be Desert Titanium
Apple's upcoming iPhone 16 Pro will come in a new color, a new report claims, and it will be sort-of ...[详细] -
Florida Man birthday Reddit meme: What it is and how to try it
Every once in a while a dormant meme resurfaces. Think: the eternal Rick Roll or the weirdly ever-pr ...[详细] -
Nancy Pelosi is right. The Jan. 6 attack needs a 9/11 Commission.
Donald J. Trump was acquitted over the weekend for inciting the Jan. 6 insurrection at the Capitol i ...[详细] -
'Star Wars Jedi: Survivor' review: A big improvement on an already really good game
Back in 2019, Electronic Arts did something few thought possible: It released a genuinely very good ...[详细] -
Best Labor Day mattress deals in 2024
Welcome in fall with a comfortable new mattress that'll help you get great sleep every night. Labor ...[详细] -
12强出炉!清远市清城区农产品区域公用品牌创意设计评选活动结果公示
12强出炉!清远市清城区农产品区域公用品牌创意设计评选活动结果公示_南方+_南方plus近日,清远市清城区农产品区域公用品牌创意设计评选活动下称“设计大赛”)线上网络投票结果出炉,共评选出12名获奖作 ...[详细]